Sound Transit is headed back to court over ST3 and high car tabs

Jan 21, 2019, 11:37 AM

lawyer free counseling...

Lawyer said faith led him to do free legal work. (AP)


Lawyers behind a class action lawsuit are appealing a lower court’s decision to toss the case over ST3.

The lawsuit was filed last year on behalf of a half dozen voters in Pierce, King, and Snohomish Counties over ST3 – the $54 billion light rail expansion package approved by voters in 2016.

“It’s our position that when the Legislature drafted the enabling statute for the Sound Transit 3 motor vehicle excise tax they made quite a mistake in how they put that together,” Joel Ard the attorney behind the lawsuit said.

“They amended an existing statute without setting it forth in full and don’t fall within any of the accepted guidelines for doing that so the statute as a whole is unconstitutional,” Ard added.

It’s a complicated argument. But Ard says the bottom line is if you’re going to change the existing law you have to clearly explain that change. So when people read the proposed statute, they know what kind of change you’re making. He says that didn’t happen here.

“What they did in this case, is there is an existing valuation schedule and the Legislature said — in a very sort of tortured and backhanded way – ‘don’t use the existing schedule, use one that got repealed 16 years ago.’ But they don’t spell out the content of the repealed schedule,” Ard said

He argues, among other things, the full text of the old vehicle valuation system should have been included in the initiative – and because it wasn’t, it is in violation of the state constitution.

Fighting over ST3 in court

The lawsuit led to a spectacle of a court hearing in Pierce County in September, where Sound Transit lawyers brought in giant props to argue their side and defend the legislation as constitutional.

In that hearing, Ard asked Pierce County Judge Kathryn Nelson to look at whether the Legislature violated the constitution by not including the full text. But after an hour of very technical arguments by Ard, and attorneys for Sound Transit, and the State Attorney General’s Office (which argued in support of Sound Transit) Judge Nelson quickly ruled. But not before admitting she may be out of her depth.

“There are many aspects about this case that I think are way above my pay grade, and I have a feeling that there will be opportunities for those people with that pay grade to double check my work,” Nelson said, eluding to the likely appeal to a higher court.

She then quickly ruled in favor of Sound Transit that the authorizing bill was constitutional and tossed the lawsuit, clearing the way for Sound Transit to continue collecting car tabs at the higher rate.

A win for commuters

Sound Transit, Spokesman Geoff Patrick said the ruling in September was a big win for commuters.

“The lawsuit that was heard today was without merit and it was great to hear the judge promptly reject it,” Patrick said.

Ard did not appeal right away – but says he filed with the state court of appeals now because he believes his case is stronger.

“The Supreme Court has ruled again on this topic of how the Legislature has to draft amendatory bills,” Ard said. “That was in the charter schools case that came down in October – after our summary judgement hearing. They really emphasized the importance of this section of the [state] constitution and we think if you look at that case and all the other cases that the supreme court has taken, that the Legislature really fell well outside the lines when they drafted and passed this statute.”

Ard has said he expects the case to eventually play out in the state Supreme Court.

If he wins?

“The legislation would fall and that would mean that Sound Transit lacks the authorization to collect the 0.8 percent ST3 Motor Vehicle Excise Tax. They’d have to refund what they’ve collected to date and have to stop collecting it going forward,” Ard said.

Sound Transit has not commented on the appeal.

MyNorthwest News

Semi Bird...

Bill Kaczaraba

Semi Bird wins endorsement for governor from state GOP

Republican candidate for governor Semi Bird has won the endorsement of the GOP state convention on Saturday.

7 hours ago

Quarantine hotel...

Jake Chapman, KIRO 7 News

International students remain in quarantine in King County hotel after measles exposure

RENTON, Wash. — A group of over a dozen international students from Africa are in quarantine in a King County hotel after they were exposed to measles. As of Friday, according to several host families for the students, they have been in quarantine since April 10. None of the students have tested positive for measles […]

10 hours ago

Washington State University (WSU) President Kirk Schulz, left, and his wife Noel Schulz speak durin...

Steve Coogan

Washington State University President Kirk Schulz announces plan to retire in 2025

Washington State University President Kirk Schulz announced his plan Friday to retire in June 2025. He has held the position since 2016.

1 day ago

wsp charges protest I-5...

Heather Bosch and Kate Stone

Charges filed against protesters who shut down I-5 in Seattle

Charges have been filed against six protesters who were involved in the pro-Palestinian protest that shut down I-5 in Seattle on Jan. 6.

1 day ago

Image: The Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) closed part of Interstate 90 on Fr...

Steve Coogan

I-90 reopens after a closure due to an emergency tree removal

I-90 reopened after needing to close Friday afternoon due to an emergency tree removal, the Washington State of Transportation said Friday.

1 day ago

The WNBA's Seattle Storm opens new facility in Interbay. (Seattle Storm X post)...

The MyNorthwest staff with wire reports

Seattle Storm unveil new Interbay practice facility, alternative uniforms

The $64 million facility in the Interbay neighborhood is an upgrade for the WNBA's Seattle Storm, which also debuted new alternate uniforms.

2 days ago

Sound Transit is headed back to court over ST3 and high car tabs