DAVE ROSS

Ross: Does Steve Mnuchin know the definition of ‘shall’?

May 8, 2019, 6:53 AM | Updated: 11:00 am

mnuchin...

Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

(Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

The secretary of the Treasury, Steve Mnuchin, has issued a letter explaining that the IRS cannot lawfully provide President Trump’s tax returns. Because the request lacks a legitimate legislative purpose.

RELATED: Trump, social media, and silencing trolls
RELATED: Are Trump’s policies intentionally incoherent?

That has surprised many people, because the language of the law on this says “Upon written request from the chairman of the Committee on Ways and Means … the Secretary shall furnish such committee with any return…”

So I checked with the various online dictionaries — both American and British. And they all agree. The word “shall” is used in laws, regulations, or directives to express what is mandatory.

So then I double-checked with reporter David Fahrenthold at the Washington Post.

“The law says he shall do it,” he told me.

No wiggle room.

“The law says if the congressional committee asks the treasury secretary shall produce the document,” he said.

As for Secretary Mnuchin’s demand that there be a legislative purpose?

“That loophole does not exist in the law. So he’s breaking the law,” Fahrenthold said.

That doesn’t seem likely — that a high government official would try to break the law. All I can think is that there must exist somewhere a Supreme Court ruling re-defining “shall” as meaning not “mandatory,” but “optional.”

Then again, wait a minute! The Ten Commandments just got a whole lot easier to follow! But it does sort of ruin the Second Amendment.

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave Ross

car culture...

Dave Ross

Ross: Are we killing car culture? Or is car culture killing the US?

I don’t think the question is whether we're going to "kill" our car culture. The real question is can we stop our car culture from killing the U.S.?

4 days ago

drivers data insurance...

Dave Ross

Ross: As cars release driving data to insurance, is your driving my business?

Every move you make, every swerve you take, every lane change you fake – someone’s watching you. Do drivers have a right to keep driving data private?

11 days ago

rent control...

Dave Ross

Ross: Rent control was never the answer in Wash.

The rent control bill died in the Washington State Legislature this week, even though Democrats control both houses.

1 month ago

end of democracy...

Dave Ross

Ross: Conservative activist earns applause for pledging an ‘end of Democracy’

The theme from Jack Posobiec's speech is that Jan. 6 was a righteous attack not on democracy, but on those who threaten democracy.

1 month ago

Image: Rep. Lauren Boebert, R-Colorado, is seen on Capitol Hill on Jan. 6, 2023. (Photo: Alex Brand...

Dave Ross

Ross: Voters can help cull bad politicians from the herd early

Let's remember that just about every occupant of a higher office once occupied a lower office, and was put there by us, Dave Ross says.

1 month ago

Super Bowl celebration...

Dave Ross

Ross: The NFL does it again

The NFL once again put on a show that was able to keep me tuned in for four hours even though I had no stake in either team.

2 months ago

Ross: Does Steve Mnuchin know the definition of ‘shall’?