How a legal challenge to I-976 might play out in court

Nov 7, 2019, 9:58 AM
I-976 lawsuit, therapeutic court, forgery, fraud...

With both King County and the City of Seattle preparing lawsuits against Tim Eyman’s soon-to-be-passed I-976, how might a legal challenge play out? According to former Washington State Attorney General Rob McKenna, there’s something called a “single subject” precedent we can look to for guidance.

“Our Supreme Court has invalidated Tim Eyman measures in the past for violating single subject,” McKenna told KIRO Radio’s Dave Ross. “Initiative 695, which was his original $30 car tab measure, was struck down on those very grounds.”

“Single subject” rules exist to prevent a practice called “log-rolling,” when single initiatives contain multiple topics that are not necessarily related to each other.

I-976 fallout: Inslee postpones all upcoming WSDOT projects

“The idea is … that you should be able to vote on a single proposal that is not held captive by something else that’s in the bill,” McKenna described.

For I-976, reducing car tabs to $30 is just one of a handful of measures the legislation calls for. It also implements a laundry list of tax and fee reductions, including:

  • Repealing of a state statute that allows the imposition of a vehicle fee for a Transportation Benefit District
  • Repealing of the local option motor vehicle excise tax for passenger-only ferry service
  • Repealing of motor vehicle weight fees
  • Repealing of motor home weight fees

Because of that, McKenna sees a possible scenario where a court looks at I-976, and rules that its various requirements need to be implemented piecemeal.

“The court could look at the $30 car tabs and these other statutes that are related to fees for vehicles, and might conceivably conclude that they would have to be separately adopted,” he noted. “It’s a tricky question for the court.”

An alternate roadblock

Outside of the single subject precedent, Sound Transit has another potential argument it could make against implementing I-976.

“If the [car tab] revenue has all been bonded, that could be a basis for blocking the initiative from taking effect,” said McKenna.

He cites an idea known as “impairment of contract,” which restricts the passage of laws that conflict with existing contracts entered into by the government.

The next steps for Sound Transit in the wake of I-976

“Under the impairment of contract theory, Sound Transit might come in and argue that they’ve already bonded against the higher level of car tab revenues,” he outlined. “Therefore, even though car tab revenue will still be around at a much lower level, you can’t reduce them, at least not at this point.”

I-976 does attempt to address that by requiring Sound Transit to refinance its already-issued bonds by the end of March 2020, but as McKenna points out, “it isn’t clear you can require that in an initiative.”

Dave Ross on KIRO Radio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Radio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross

car tabs, Orting...
Dave Ross

Ross: Did you vote for I-976 car tab cuts in 2019? Wish granted

While a vaccine mandate cost the ferry system 7% of its staff, let’s remember this is happening in a state that was ready to impose bigger cuts two years ago.
15 hours ago
Dave Ross

Ross: May we live long and prosper with our vaccine choices

Talk show host Dennis Praeger decided to put it all on the line to prove he’s right about vaccines.
2 days ago
Flu vaccine...
MyNorthwest Staff

A new ‘universal’ flu-COVID shot on the horizon, says local MD

Mercer Island’s Dr. Gordon Cohen discusses how future iterations of the COVID mRNA vaccine could also treat seasonal flu.
3 days ago
Crypto power plant...
Dave Ross

Ross: The troubling downside behind megawatts of crypto-power

Power plants feeding Bitcoin miners will create jobs, but they’ll do it by pumping CO2 into the air in service of creating more of the currency.
3 days ago
Dave Ross

Ross: The real reason people don’t want to return to work

The extra unemployment benefits were cut off in September and most states elected not to continue them. Yet, millions of workers are still holding out.
6 days ago
Shatner, space...
Dave Ross

Ross: Shatner’s emotional response over trip to space exactly what we needed to hear

Space travel is a trip that every billionaire who thinks he’s a master of the universe needs to take as soon as possible.
7 days ago

Sponsored Articles


Medicare open enrollment for 2022 starts Oct. 15 and SHIBA can help!

Washington State Office of the Insurance Commissioner SPONSORED — Medicare’s Open Enrollment Period, also called the Annual Election Period, is Oct. 15 to Dec. 7. During this time, people enrolled in Medicare can: Switch from Original Medicare to a Medicare Advantage plan and vice versa. Join, drop or switch a Part D prescription drug plan, […]

How to Have a Stress-Free Real Estate Experience

The real estate industry has adapted and sellers are taking full advantage of new real estate models. One of which is Every Door Real Estate.
IQ Air

How Poor Air Quality Is Affecting Our Future Athletes

You cannot control your child’s breathing environment 100% of the time, but you can make a huge impact.
Swedish Health Services

Special Coverage: National Prostate Cancer Awareness Month

There are a wide variety of treatment options available for men with prostate cancer. The most technologically advanced treatment option in the Northwest is Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy using the CyberKnife platform.
Marysville Police Department

Police Opportunities in a Growing, Supportive Washington Community

Marysville PD is looking for both lateral and entry level officers. Begin or continue your career in law enforcement for a growing, supportive community.

Small, Minority-Owned Businesses in King County and Pierce County Can Now Apply For $10,000 Relief Grants Through Comcast RISE

Businesses in King County and Pierce County can apply beginning on October 1, 2021, at www.ComcastRISE.com for a chance to receive a $10,000 relief grant.
How a legal challenge to I-976 might play out in court