What’s the likelihood of another Washington (DC) state?

Apr 27, 2021, 12:23 PM

D.C. statehood...

An empty Pennsylvania Avenue between the White House and U.S. Capitol building on Jan.15, 2021, in Washington, DC. (Photo by Samuel Corum/Getty Images)

(Photo by Samuel Corum/Getty Images)

With more talk about granting statehood to Washington, D.C., Washington Post reporter (and D.C. resident) David Fahrenthold weighs in on the likelihood of a 51st state.

US House changes from Census may have implications for future elections

“The momentum behind it, I think, is kind of at the high water mark that it’s ever been, which is not nearly high enough to get it passed,” Fahrenthold explained. “It’s just passed the House of Representatives. I don’t think it has the support to overcome the filibuster in the Senate. In fact, I know it doesn’t because I think everybody recognizes it would add two more Democratic senators and one more Democratic representative. The Republicans who make up almost half of the Senate would not — or half of the Senate — would not want that.”

“So you hear some arguments about, well, D.C. shouldn’t be a state because it doesn’t have any farms, or D.C. shouldn’t be a state because it doesn’t have any factories. But really, nobody wants to add two — or Republicans don’t want to add two Democratic senators,” he added.

Fahrenthold does think it might be more likely for D.C. to become a state if the United States had 49 states and not 50.

“You laugh, but I honestly think that if we had 49 states now and adding D.C. would get us to 50 that this would seem like a much more plausible idea,” he said. “But the fact that is we’re at 50 now, such a good even number, and D.C. would make it 51. And the flag would look a little odd. I’m sure you could do it, but I think that’s part of what makes this sound unnatural is where it’s such a good round number now, people don’t want to mess with it.”

In addition to the political play of statehood, Fahrenthold recognizes there are some good arguments for the idea.

“There are a lot of great arguments for D.C. statehood. We have more residents in D.C. than Vermont or Wyoming, we’re bigger than some states,” he said. “We have no representation in the Senate and our only representative in Congress can’t vote. So this huge amount of people is not really represented at all in the legislative branch.”

“That said, the arguments that are going to matter to people in Congress are arguments about boosting one political party or the other,” he continued. “Now that, there’s a long tradition of that in American history, that’s why we have two Dakotas instead of one, because people wanted to add two more, wanted four Republican senators instead of two way back when. But given that calculation, it’s going to take a strong Democratic majority in the Senate to make this a likely outcome.”

Listen to Seattle’s Morning News weekday mornings from 5 – 9 a.m. on KIRO Radio, 97.3 FM, and on your smart speaker as well. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross

Palestinians flee to northern Gaza as Israeli tanks block the Salah al-Din road in the central Gaza...

Dave Ross

Ross: When deterrence doesn’t work with the Gaza War

Beyond the debate over morality, the Gaza War is teaching us how a conflict between two groups can rip away the veneer of civilization.

6 days ago

Swimmers take part in the annual Sydney Skinny....

Dave Ross

Ross: Beaches in the buff don’t scream ‘Seattle’

It's not necessarily lewd to go naked. It's just that this is Seattle, not Brazil. The climate here doesn't exactly scream "nude."

11 days ago

FILE - Former President Donald Trump waits to take the witness stand during his civil fraud trial a...

Dave Ross

Ross: Turning the Constitution on itself

In a hearing before the DC Court of Appeals, Donald Trump’s attorney argued that the First Amendment protects his political speech and that the gag order against him in the election tampering case is unconstitutional.

12 days ago

Image: Washington Louis sorts through cans of food at the LifeNet4Families community-based food pan...

Dave Ross

Ross: Helping the hungry comes with gratitude that goes both ways

Last week a group of us from KIRO Radio – Management, Sales, and On-Air staff – volunteered at the White Center Food Bank.

13 days ago

Sen. Markwayne Mullin. (Getty Images)...

Dave Ross

Ross: Politics is war by other means

We all know that bullies are a problem. It’s bad enough in the classroom, but it’s really bad when that attitude persists into adulthood and plays out among people in important positions.

17 days ago

Nurse patient...

Dave Ross

Ross: Artificial Intelligence bringing a non-human approach to health care

I'm at the age where after a doctor’s visit I’ll get a form letter basically saying -- we just paid one of your medical bills, please prove it's legitimate.

18 days ago

What’s the likelihood of another Washington (DC) state?