Former state AG: ‘Awful lot of precedent’ in the US for requiring vaccination

Jun 18, 2021, 5:09 AM
Medical workers and pedestrians cross an intersection outside of the Houston Methodist Hospital on June 9, 2021, in Houston, Texas. Houston Methodist Hospital suspended 178 employees without pay for 14 days for their refusal to comply with its COVID-19 vaccine requirement. (Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)
(Photo by Brandon Bell/Getty Images)

A federal judge dismissed a lawsuit brought by employees of Houston Methodist Hospital, who said that the hospital had no right to force them to get the COVID-19 vaccination.

UW Virology head: ‘I hope we give science benefit of doubt’ in next pandemic

“There’s just an awful lot of precedent in our country for the idea that to protect public health and safety, you can require school children to be vaccinated before you go to school. You can require adults to be vaccinated to go back to work,” explained Rob McKenna, former state attorney general.

“The law goes all the way back to 1905 when a man named Jacobson challenged mandatory smallpox vaccination in Lowell, Massachusetts, that had been ordered by the local health board, and he lost because — and this is very interesting because if you read the opinion of the majority, it sounds very similar to the opinion issued by the district court judge in Texas this week,” McKenna added.

The reasons given in the Jacobson case were that, one, there’s a public health reason to require vaccination. Two, the vaccine had been proven to be safe, or safe enough. And three, Jacobson failed to demonstrate that there was a special circumstance that would justify him not having to be vaccinated.

“So he had to pay the $5 fine,” McKenna said. “They were fining people for not being vaccinated. In Houston, the court said, look, I don’t agree that this vaccine should be considered experimental. The vaccines are being dispensed under an emergency use authorization from the FDA, but hundreds of millions of people have received them. And so he said, look, just as the Jacobson Court did in 1905, he said, this is safe.”

“Number two, in this case, it’s an employer and the employer is a hospital. And so there’s a strong public policy reason for hospitals to want their employees to be vaccinated when they’re going to be around patients,” McKenna continued. “So he threw the case out. They’re going to appeal it, but I think they’ll lose because not only the law, but the public policy rationale here is really strong.”

While this could have to do with the nature of the lead plaintiff’s job, who was a nurse at a hospital, McKenna thinks it would stand no matter what.

“The federal government has issued guidance for all employers stating that employers may require vaccination as a condition of employment,” he said. “Now, they’re not forcing people, like tying them and vaccinating them, but you have to make a choice if the employer imposes that rule. You have to decide whether to get vaccinated or to leave the job.”

The exceptions to a vaccine requirement are if the person has a religious exemption or disability that would prevent them from being vaccinated.

“In both cases, if you’re able to successfully persuade the employer or court that you have a disability or you deserve a religious exemption, the employer has to provide an accommodation for you as an employee,” McKenna noted. “But the employee has to go along with the accommodation. So the accommodation might be a change in job duties, you’re not around patients or customers. It may mean you have to keep wearing a mask when others don’t. You have to be socially distanced.”

“So even in the cases involving those two exceptions, where an accommodation must be provided for the employee, it imposes a burden on the employee as well, which is, I think, pretty reasonable,” he said.

‘Delta variant should be that warning flag,’ says Tacoma ER doctor

This also would apply to employers requiring masks as a condition of employment.

“Employers are allowed to impose requirements they believe are reasonably necessary to protect other employees, to protect customers, or in the case of a hospital, to protect patients,” McKenna said. “I think that all those things would be upheld given how dangerous this virus is, and how contagious it is.”

Listen to Seattle’s Morning News weekday mornings from 5 – 9 a.m. on KIRO Radio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Dave Ross on KIRO Radio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Radio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross

Dave Ross

Ross: The real reason people don’t want to return to work

The extra unemployment benefits were cut off in September and most states elected not to continue them. Yet, millions of workers are still holding out.
3 days ago
Shatner, space...
Dave Ross

Ross: Shatner’s emotional response over trip to space exactly what we needed to hear

Space travel is a trip that every billionaire who thinks he’s a master of the universe needs to take as soon as possible.
4 days ago
Dave Ross

Ross: Choosing the fully-vaccinated airline that makes you feel safest

Two airlines – Southwest and American –both based in Texas, have decided to stick with their plans to require employees to get vaccinated.
5 days ago
Jan. 6, US Capitol...
MyNorthwest Staff

Committee investigating Jan. 6 pushes for details from White House aides

Washington Post's David Fahrenthold discusses the investigation into Jan. 6, with subpoenas now sent to some of former President Trump's closest aides.
6 days ago
Dave Ross

Ross: Down the rabbit hole as TikTok challenges take on life of their own

Just remember kids, you’re responsible for your conduct no matter what website put you up to it, whether it's TikTok or somewhere else.
6 days ago
MyNorthwest Staff

Mercer Island MD: New accessible COVID treatment is ‘necessary step’

A new COVID-19 treatment is on the horizon. Merck’s new COVID treatment — available in pill form — has been submitted to the FDA.
7 days ago

Sponsored Articles


How to Have a Stress-Free Real Estate Experience

The real estate industry has adapted and sellers are taking full advantage of new real estate models. One of which is Every Door Real Estate.
IQ Air

How Poor Air Quality Is Affecting Our Future Athletes

You cannot control your child’s breathing environment 100% of the time, but you can make a huge impact.
Swedish Health Services

Special Coverage: National Prostate Cancer Awareness Month

There are a wide variety of treatment options available for men with prostate cancer. The most technologically advanced treatment option in the Northwest is Stereotactic Body Radiation Therapy using the CyberKnife platform.
Marysville Police Department

Police Opportunities in a Growing, Supportive Washington Community

Marysville PD is looking for both lateral and entry level officers. Begin or continue your career in law enforcement for a growing, supportive community.

Small, Minority-Owned Businesses in King County and Pierce County Can Now Apply For $10,000 Relief Grants Through Comcast RISE

Businesses in King County and Pierce County can apply beginning on October 1, 2021, at www.ComcastRISE.com for a chance to receive a $10,000 relief grant.
Courtesy of JWatch Photography....
Experience Anacortes

Summer Fun Activities in Anacortes

With minimal travel time required and every activity under the sun, Anacortes is the perfect vacation spot for all ages.
Former state AG: ‘Awful lot of precedent’ in the US for requiring vaccination