Would Inslee bill making it illegal to lie about election fraud survive a court challenge?

Jan 28, 2022, 1:19 PM | Updated: Jan 31, 2022, 9:47 am
Inslee election fraud...
Gov. Jay Inslee. (Office of the Governor)
(Office of the Governor)

State lawmakers heard testimony on Friday for a bill from Gov. Jay Inslee, which would make it a misdemeanor for elected leaders or candidates to spread unfounded allegations of election fraud. But could his proposal stand up to a court challenge?

Election fraud narrative becomes common thread among state’s Republican candidate

In a news release sent out shortly after his testimony in the state Legislature, Inslee detailed how the bill — sponsored by state Sen. David Frockt (D-Seattle) — was drafted in consultation with constitutional law scholars Laurence Tribe and Catherine Ross.

Tribe is a professor emeritus at Harvard University, having authored “American Constitutional Law” in 1978, which is acknowledged by many as a canonical work in the field. Despite admitting that he “can’t say with complete confidence” whether Gov. Inslee’s bill would survive a judicial challenge, Tribe expressed confidence that it “respects the texts and purposes of the First Amendment and the precedents construing it.”

“I can say that it represents at the very least a thoroughly sensible, responsible, and good faith effort to address a serious problem imperiling democracy,” Tribe detailed in Inslee’s release.

Catherine Ross  — whose work as a constitutional law professor at George Washington University focuses on the First Amendment — first became aware of the bill after her past work was quoted in a Washington Post story on Inslee’s proposal. The Post cited a 2017 paper from Ross that explained the scarcity of helpful judicial precedents directly related to “the constitutionality of campaign deception statutes.”

“But on reading this piece I agreed with the governor that these are exceptional times in which lies about the results of the last election pose a realistic threat,” she clarified in testimony delivered to the Washington State Legislature. “I thought Washington’s interests were so important I wanted this bill to be done right, and I reached out and offered to help. I consulted and helped craft the language which I do believe addresses the First Amendment problems.”

As the Washington Post points out, though, courts have also struck down laws attempting to criminalize false political speech in the past.

That includes a 2007 ruling from Washington state’s Supreme Court, which negated a law that had sought to prohibit candidates from lying about their opponents. Seven years later, a federal judge in Ohio struck down a law that had allowed the government to regulate and censor false political speech.

Amid run for Congress, Loren Culp continues to push election fraud narrative

Inslee’s bill seeks to account for that legal precedent by focusing on the U.S. Supreme Court’s 1969 Brandenburg v. Ohio decision, which established that any speech inciting “imminent lawless action” isn’t protected under the First Amendment. Using that standard, Inslee points to the Jan. 6 riot at the U.S. Capitol as proof that allowing election falsehoods to spread has the potential to directly incite lawless and harmful behavior.

“We cannot afford, and we should not have to endure, another insurrection like January 6, 2021,” Inslee testified on Friday. “But violent insurrection is not the only threat to democracy. This bill takes on all attempts to spur violence through election lies. Diminished acceptance of election results threatens our system of government and the people who serve.”

Others have warned that meeting the standard laid out in Brandenburg has traditionally proven to be a tall order. That was pointed out earlier this week by Lawfare, a national security blog that works in concert with the Brookings Institute.

“The bill would be ineffective because the Brandenburg standard is incredibly difficult to meet, and it is hard to conceive of many false election claims that would surpass this hurdle,” Lawfare’s Jeff Kosseff posited in a Tuesday story. “Although prosecutors would have trouble convicting people under this bill, it still raises substantial free speech concerns due to its chilling effect.”

The bill remains under consideration in the state Senate’s Government & Elections Committee.

Local News

west seattle bridge...
Dalton Day

Concrete strike’s impact on West Seattle Bridge timeline unclear as SDOT makes final pours

SDOT still hopes to open the West Seattle Bridge in “mid-2022." A to-be-announced, updated timeline will be delivered on June 9.
19 hours ago
King County interim Sheriff Patti Cole-Tindall...
MyNorthwest Staff

King County confirms Patti Cole-Tindall as new Sheriff

The King County Council voted unanimously to confirm Patti Cole-Tindall as the new King County Sheriff on Tuesday.
19 hours ago
Dalton Day

Seattle loses battle over Burke-Gilman Trail’s ‘missing link’ as project funds sunset

A spate of legal challenges over the 1.4-mile stretch of the Burke-Gilman Trail's missing link jeopardizes its completion.
19 hours ago
A look at the crash scene.  Concern that one of the drivers went off the bridge.  Search is underwa...
MyNorthwest Staff

22-year-old victim identified in fatal Ship Canal Bridge collision

The deadly crash on southbound I-5 in Seattle's University District this morning killed 22-year-old Jordan Shelley of Seattle.
19 hours ago
MyNorthwest Staff

Instance of monkeypox investigated in King County amid ‘growing international outbreak’

A presumptive case of monkeypox is being investigated in King County, according to Public Health, Seattle and King County.
2 days ago
KIRO Newsradio Newsdesk

As pandemic-fueled surge in online shopping slows, Amazon subleases warehouse space

Amazon is planning to sublease some of its warehouse space now that the pandemic-fueled surge in online shopping has eased.
2 days ago

Sponsored Articles


Anacortes – A Must Visit Summertime Destination

While Anacortes is certainly on the way to the San Juan Islands (SJI), it is not just a destination to get to the ferry… Anacortes is a destination in and of itself!

Ready for your 2022 Alaskan Adventure with Celebrity Cruises?

Celebrity Cruises SPONSORED — A round-trip Alaska cruise from Seattle is an amazing treat for you and a loved one. Not only are you able to see and explore some of the most incredible and visually appealing natural sights on the planet, but you’re also able to relax and re-energize while aboard a luxury cruise […]

Compassion International Is Determined to ‘Fill’ a Unique Type of Football ‘Stadium’

Compassion International SPONSORED — During this fall’s football season—and as the pandemic continues to impact the entire globe—one organization has been urging caring individuals to help it “fill” a unique type of “stadium” in order to make a lasting difference in the lives of many. Compassion International’s distinctive Fill the Stadium (FtS, fillthestadium.com) initiative provides […]

What are the Strongest, Greenest, Best Windows?

Lake Washington Windows & Doors SPONSORED — Fiberglass windows are an excellent choice for window replacement due to their fundamental strength and durability. There is no other type of window that lasts as long as fiberglass; so why go with anything else? Fiberglass windows are 8x stronger than vinyl, lower maintenance than wood, more thermally […]

COVID Vaccine is a Game-Changer for Keeping our Kids Healthy

Snohomish Health District SPONSORED — Cheers to the parents and guardians who keep their kids safe and healthy. The dad who cooks a meal with something green in it, even though he’s tired and drive-thru burgers were tempting. The mom who calms down the little one who loudly and resolutely does NOT want to brush […]
Experience Anacortes

Coastal Christmas Celebration Week in Anacortes

With minimal travel time required and every activity under the sun, Anacortes is the perfect vacation spot for all ages.
Would Inslee bill making it illegal to lie about election fraud survive a court challenge?