Times’ lawsuit reveals answers to Durkan’s missing texts, leads to reforms

May 9, 2022, 5:24 PM

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan speaks at a press conference at Seattle City Hall on August 11, 2020 in ...

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan speaks at a press conference at Seattle City Hall on August 11, 2020 in Seattle, Washington. (Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)

(Photo by Karen Ducey/Getty Images)

The City of Seattle has agreed to pay $200,000 and a series of reforms to settle a Public Records Act lawsuit filed by the Seattle Times over former Mayor Jenny Durkan’s missing text messages and other PRA-related issues.

The Times had requested a bunch of records related mainly to see how the city was responding to protests in the wake of George Floyd’s killing in Minneapolis.

Still questions over timeline of Mayor Durkan’s missing texts in wake of forensic report

“We were trying to find out a few things,” said Times Executive Editor Michele Matasa Flores.

“One was how the city’s police force was dealing with protesters on the streets and whether they were using force appropriately or limiting the use of their force appropriately. The other was trying to find out who was making decisions both tactical and strategic about the CHOP protest zone,” she added.

“But Flores says the Times ran into a brick wall trying to get the records released to them and there were many delays, many rejections which they felt were in violation of the law. Then they also discovered – by getting certain records through other parties – that city officials had claimed they didn’t have responsive records when in fact those records did exist,” explained Flores.

“That’s how we discovered that there were quite a few missing text messages written by the mayor, and also the police chief, Carmen Best,” added Flores.

Eventually, the Times felt it was dealing with some “pretty flagrant” violations of the State Public Records Act.

“We don’t take suing lightly. We do a lot of haggling over records and trying to get access to information that the public is entitled to, we rarely file suit. But we decided in this case, it was really our only recourse,” she said, pointing out that is the only way to pursue records or violations in a case like this – a lawsuit.

While the city will have to shell out some $200,000 in fines and legal fees, Flores says the reforms are most important.

“While the city would not concede to the way I phrased it in terms of flagrant violations, they, in fact, say that they don’t have liability for these things. But they did acknowledge that they need to put better procedures into place. To me that says a lot to those of us at the Times, that says a lot” said Flores.

So, while the lawsuit won’t restore some 2000 of Durkan’s deleted text messages it reveals fresh answers and – if the city does what it’s agreed to – Flores says brings about important changes to improve transparency.

“They’re implementing software city wide, that will archive things like text messages, and other data. They will also make sure that all city-issued phones are set to retain text messages, which had not been done across the board. And in fact, we saw a completely inconsistent, almost Helter Skelter method of the city, it was hard to even tell which end was up. And that’s why they could never even get to the bottom of how these text messages mysteriously went missing. Because the systems just were not in order,” explained Flores.

The city also agreed to no longer unreasonably delay releasing records because of some internal review processes.

“We found in the course of discovery, in this case, that some records, it was decided that legally they should be released, but then they would put them through a public relations type screening for sensitive information, which is illegal. And we suspected that was going on, but this case confirmed that and led to months, many months of delay, in some cases. The city has now agreed to stop doing that,” said Flores.

“I’m a little bit nervous, this is going to be a hard one to enforce. But at least we have the language here and can turn back to it if we feel like they’re improperly delaying records,” she added.

Other details revealed during the lawsuit shed light on what exactly happened to Durkan’s texts.

“She apparently dropped her phone in Puget Sound at an undisclosed beach where she has a cabin, which is fine, we all can relate to that. I think we’re human things happen. It was after that in restoring the phone that the messages were set to delete. She says she doesn’t remember doing that. But she also acknowledges that no one else had access to the phone and could have done that,” Flores recalled.

“Now, it’s very possible that was done unintentionally. I know, I can get confused with all the settings on my phone. I get it. But was the city’s lead public official. They should have had processes and procedures in place to assure that kind of human error wouldn’t happen,” said Flores.

Seattle Mayor Harrell looks to form third public safety department for unarmed responders

The lawsuit also led to the discovery that former Seattle Police Chief Carmen Best regularly deleted her text messages.

Flores says this case could have a major impact on transparency and public access moving forward.

“If they follow through on this, the way that the settlement dictates they do, it’s enormous. I mean, who knows? What else was getting lost along the way? This case brought to light some practices that were serious violations of the law. So the potential for this having a big impact down the road is huge. We’ll see. And I hope that they follow the terms of the settlement,” said Flores.

Local News

ferguson lawsuit toxic chemicals...

L.B. Gilbert

Attorney General Ferguson lawsuit claims companies knew about toxic ‘forever chemicals’

WA Attorney General Bob Ferguson announced he was filing a lawsuit against manufacturers of "forever chemicals" that have contaminated water.

11 hours ago

franklin falls denny creek...

Frank Sumrall

Franklin Falls, Denny Creek closed for the summer

Two popular trails -- Franklin Falls and Denny Creek -- are closing by May 30 in order to kick off construction for its parking lot expansion project.

11 hours ago

Nick Rolovich lawsuit...

L.B. Gilbert

Gov. Inslee, WSU AD dismissed from Nick Rolovich lawsuit

A judge tossed out a lawsuit involving former WSU football coach Nick Rolovich who claimed he was wrongfully terminated.

11 hours ago

hurricane ridge day lodge...

Frank Sumrall

Hurricane Ridge closed indefinitely following Day Lodge fire

Olympic National Park’s Hurricane Ridge will be closed indefinitely after a fire in early May destroyed the Day Lodge.

11 hours ago

FILE - Candles are lit on a memorial wall during an anniversary memorial service at the Holy Trinit...

Associated Press

Pain and terror felt by passengers before Boeing Max crashed can be considered, judge rules

Families of passengers who died in the crash of a Boeing 737 Max in Ethiopia can seek damages for the pain and terror suffered by victims in the minutes before the plane flew nose-down into the ground, a federal judge has ruled.

11 hours ago

plane crash gig harbor...

L.B. Gilbert

Small plane crashed in Gig Harbor with faulty landing gear

An investigation is underway after a small plane crashed Tuesday morning in Gig Harbor, according to the Gig Harbor Fire Department.

11 hours ago

Sponsored Articles

Internet Washington...

Major Internet Upgrade and Expansion Planned This Year in Washington State

Comcast is investing $280 million this year to offer multi-gigabit Internet speeds to more than four million locations.

Compassion International...

Brock Huard and Friends Rally Around The Fight for First Campaign

Professional athletes are teaming up to prevent infant mortality and empower women at risk in communities facing severe poverty.

Emergency Preparedness...

Prepare for the next disaster at the Emergency Preparedness Conference

Being prepared before the next emergency arrives is key to preserving businesses and organizations of many kinds.

SHIBA volunteer...

Volunteer to help people understand their Medicare options!

If you’re retired or getting ready to retire and looking for new ways to stay active, becoming a SHIBA volunteer could be for you!

safety from crime...

As crime increases, our safety measures must too

It's easy to be accused of fearmongering regarding crime, but Seattle residents might have good reason to be concerned for their safety.

Comcast Ready for Business Fund...

Ilona Lohrey | President and CEO, GSBA

GSBA is closing the disparity gap with Ready for Business Fund

GSBA, Comcast, and other partners are working to address disparities in access to financial resources with the Ready for Business fund.

Times’ lawsuit reveals answers to Durkan’s missing texts, leads to reforms