‘Serial killers voting’: Argument over prisoner rights bill gets intense in Olympia

Jan 19, 2024, 6:24 PM | Updated: Jan 22, 2024, 10:19 am

Image: The Washington State Capitol campus in Olympia....

The Washington State Capitol campus in Olympia. (Photo: Getty Images)

(Photo: Getty Images)

People incarcerated for felony crimes, including rape and murder, in Washington prisons could get back their right to vote, serve on a jury, or run for office— if a new bill is approved this session by state lawmakers.

House Bill 2030 (HB 2030), which had a public hearing in the State Government & Tribal Relations committee Tuesday, would effectively allow anyone incarcerated in a state prison to vote or sit on a jury. Under Washington’s constitution, those convicted of “infamous crimes”— a felony that puts them in state of federal prison— are stripped of those rights during their incarceration. The state has already taken steps to change that, passing a measure in 2022 to restore voting rights immediately upon release from prison. (A PDF of the bill can be viewed here.)

The bill’s primary sponsor, Rep. Tarra Simmons, D-Bremerton, wants to take that a step further. Simmons, a formerly incarcerated person herself, has pushed for the policy since she became a lawmaker in 2020.

“Here in America, we take away the right to vote and it’s very much rooted in racism,” she told the committee. “Mass incarceration is an evolution of slavery. Other countries don’t take away your right to vote when you are convicted of a crime or sent to prison.”

Vocal opposition to the bill

Republican lawmakers are strongly opposed to the idea, saying it is the wrong time to consider such a measure at a time when violent crime is on the rise in Washington.

“So, effectively this bill says that anyone currently serving a felony sentence for vehicular homicide, or for vehicular assault, they can all sit on a jury panel on a DUI charge,” said Republican Rep. Greg Cheney (R-Battle Ground). He called the idea “absurd on its face.”

More from Olympia: Hearing on Inslee plan to compel oil company price transparency prompting accusations

The bill proposes narrowing the definition of an infamous crime to only “a state crime punishable by death.” But Cheney, alongside Rep. Sam Low, R- Lake Stevens, and Rep. Leonard Christian, R-Spokane Valley, pointed out that in 2018 the Washington Supreme Court determined that the death penalty is unconstitutional— and Gov. Jay Inslee signed a bill to formally abolish it last April. Because of that, HB 2030 would essentially extend voting rights to every incarcerated person, according to the three lawmakers.

“When I read this bill, I thought of one person: (Green River Killer) Gary Ridgway,” Low said, referring to the serial killer who murdered at least 49 teenage girls and women in Washington.

“Would Gary Ridgway’s rights be restored with this bill?” he asked Simmons during the hearing.

“Yes, they would,” she responded.

Republicans are not the only ones expressing concerns with the idea. Brian Hatfield, a spokesperson for Democratic Secretary of State Steve Hobbs said they interpret the legislation to allow for people serving felony sentences to run for office. Hatfield said Hobbs has strong objections to “restoring the ability to vote until a person has paid their debt to society.” He also pointed out the logistical concerns associated with transporting people from prison to serve on juries or perform the duties of an elected office.

Those currently behind bars had a chance to speak as well—testifying via Zoom from the Washington Corrections Center in Shelton.

‘Righting a historical wrong’

Charles Longshore, an incarcerated Skokomish tribal member, told lawmakers the bill is “righting a historical wrong.” He said indigenous people are incarcerated at the highest rate of any race or ethnicity in Washington. Longshore is currently serving a sentence for second-degree murder but said, “Regardless of incarceration, I’m a member of our state’s original people. That should count for something. I shouldn’t be here in 2024 fighting for an Indian to have the right to vote.”

He told lawmakers he is at a point in life where he is rehabilitated but feels disenfranchised.

Derrick Jones, the current president of the Black Prisoners Caucus at the WCC, echoed those sentiments.

“I’ve been incarcerated for 26 years,” Jones said while urging lawmakers to consider the impacts of the bill on people like himself. “When a person comes into the knowledge of his social responsibility, we begin to feel like we’re connected to something that’s greater than ourselves.”

“Unfortunately, I’ve also observed the tragedy of isolation— of what it looks like when a person feels like they’re disconnected or that they’ve been silenced.”

More from Kate Stone: No more ‘spring forward’ if new bill passes Wash. State Legislature

Rep. Simmons agreed, telling committee members there is no public safety threat in expanding civil rights. “They’re not going to use their ballot to commit a crime. They’re not going to use their ballot to hold somebody up or anything like that. So, I really wonder why we take it away.”

An estimated 4.6 million people in the United States cannot vote due to a felony conviction. There are around 13,000 people in Washington’s prisons, although not all of them are citizens. If Washington enacts HB 2030, it would join only Maine, Vermont and the District of Columbia in allowing prisoners to vote.

You can read more of Kate Stone’s stories here. Follow Kate on X, formerly known as Twitter, or email her here.

MyNorthwest Politics

Image: Then-Republican gubernatorial candidate Loren Culp smiles while greeting supporters as he ar...

Julia Dallas

Rep. Maycumber threatens legal action against Loren Culp amid social media tirade

On Tuesday, Maycumber's office announced it sent a cease-and-desist letter to Loren Culp after a barrage of social media posts.

15 hours ago

mcginn child charges...

Frank Sumrall and Steve Coogan

Son of former Seattle Mayor McGinn pleads not guilty to child pornography charges

Jack McGinn -- son of former Seattle Mayor Mike McGinn -- has been charged with two felony counts related to child pornography.

1 day ago

Costco vs. Boeing...

Bill Kaczaraba

A study in contrasts: Costco vs. Boeing

A recent poll conducted by DMH Research sheds light on how we perceive major companies like Amazon, Starbucks and Microsoft.

4 days ago

Image: President Joe Biden speaks about his administration's work to lower the cost of breathing tr...

Heather Bosch and Steve Coogan

Washington official dismisses concerns Joe Biden may be left off election ballot

The Washington Secretary of State's office is brushing off concerns President Joe Biden won't be on the state's general election ballot.

5 days ago

high capacity magazines...

Frank Sumrall

Judge rules Washington’s ban on high-capacity magazines is unconstitutional

Washington's ban on high-capacity magazines is unconstitutional, at least according to Cowlitz County Superior Court Judge Gary Bashor.

8 days ago

oregon drug possession...

Kate Stone

Oregon ends decriminalization of drugs, joins Washington in pushing jail or treatment

Oregon Democratic Gov. Tina Kotek signed into law a bill that recriminalizes the possession of small amounts of drugs.

15 days ago

‘Serial killers voting’: Argument over prisoner rights bill gets intense in Olympia