DAVE ROSS

Everett’s lawsuit against Purdue Pharma sounds more like a case against ‘El Chapo’

Mar 9, 2017, 12:12 PM

The City of Everett is blaming Purdue Pharma for the city’s opioid epidemic. If you read the lawsuit, it doesn’t sound like the city is suing a corporation as much as they are suing El Chapo.

Additional reading: City of Everett v. Purdue Pharma

The city says this pharmaceutical company was deliberately negligent in the distribution of Oxycontin and they want compensation for having to deal with the aftermath.

The charges are breathtaking.

“The lawsuit claims Purdue is responsible for knowingly, recklessly, and/or negligently supplying Oxycontin to obviously suspicious physicians and pharmacies and enabling the illegal diversion of Oxycontin into the black market,” former State Attorney General Rob McKenna explained. “It’s a strong claim, but this company has had trouble before.”

Indeed. When McKenna was attorney general he settled a lawsuit with the company in 2007 for not maintaining adequate control over suspicious order and for not notifying authorities for suspecting illegal activity.

And McKenna says Purdue is not free from another lawsuit — double jeopardy does not apply in this case.

“We settled litigation and they agreed to follow a set of regulations that involved tighter controls over who received the drugs they ship,” McKenna said.

Now, McKenna says, the City of Everett is claiming that Purdue has not complied with all those agreements and the company continues to allow their product to be diverted into the black market through suspicious pharmacies.

And that’s just the beginning. Other allegations against Purdue allege the company tried to expand the market for Oxycontin by engaging in campaigns to exaggerate the benefits and needs of the drug while minimizing the risks that go along with it. This could put Purdue on the hook for the expenses to the city, which are considerable – weaning people from drugs, rehab, police time. How high could it go?

The tab from the city could run into millions, McKenna says.

“Other communities have been devastated as well,” he added. “That could run into the billions and put them out of business or put them out of the business of making Oxycontin.”

Ross: Should doctors write the homeless prescriptions for housing in Seattle?

To be fair, Purdue did do some commendable things after McKenna’s lawsuit. That included reformulating the drug to make it impossible to crush and smoke.

“But, obviously, Everett believes they have evidence that [Purdue Pharma] continues to sell and abuse this drug,” he said.

On the other hand, while Purdue may have promoted it, they weren’t forcing anyone to use it or take it. Why wouldn’t this kind of approach be used against a gun manufacturer who may have noticed a pattern of sales to gangs? Or online retailers, who are selling drones to terrorists?

Pharmaceuticals, McKenna says, are regulated in a way that drones and handguns are not. If a gun manufacturer was looking the other way while guns were being diverted to gangs they might face claims. He says online retailers probably wouldn’t.

“I don’t know if Everett will be able to win or not, but we’ll see if Purdue can make its own case or not,” he said.

The lawsuit will likely take years.

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave Ross

forever chemicals living defensively...

Dave Ross

Ross: Living defensively has its limits when facing ‘forever chemicals’

The trouble is that "living defensively" has its limits – as we heard when 3M lost control of its "forever chemicals."

3 days ago

Image: In this photo illustration, the logos of social media applications Instagram, Facebook, Link...

Dave Ross

Ross: If you hope the government will save kids from social media, think again

Social media firm TikTok must sell itself to a non-Chinese company, or it goes dark in the U.S. But that law is headed straight to court.

6 days ago

kristi noem book...

Dave Ross

Ross: Gov. Kristi Noem’s new book includes alleged meetings with dictators, dead dogs

Did South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem meet with North Korean dictator Kim Jong Un as she claims in her new book?

20 days ago

Image: Sound Transit tested train service on the 2 Line between southern Bellevue and Microsoft for...

Dave Ross

Ross: We built it, and they had better come

About 17,500 people attended the opening of the Eastside light rail line. It shows a curiosity about getting to Redmond without driving there.

25 days ago

Photo: A pro-Palestinian demonstration takes place outside the link light rail station at the Unive...

Dave Ross

Ross: Does the right to protest outweigh the right to learn?

When does a protest cross the line? I can answer that. When it devolves into violence, obviously it crosses a line.

27 days ago

privacy pods...

Dave Ross

Ross: Tracking employees’ vital signs at work via privacy pods, what could go wrong?

I saw a Bloomberg story about the latest innovation to reduce your stress level at work: Privacy pods.

2 months ago

Everett’s lawsuit against Purdue Pharma sounds more like a case against ‘El Chapo’