DAVE ROSS

You can be anything you want to be, or can you?

Sep 13, 2012, 8:24 AM | Updated: 8:25 am

I hesitate even to mention this study, because of all the nations on earth, America is the one nation that prides itself on giving anyone who comes here — legally, anyway– the chance to be whatever they want to be.

But according to University of Michigan sociologist Fabian Pfeffer, you actually can’t.

What determines whether you get somewhere in life is your parents’ wealth. Education matters, so does occupation. But what tips the balance is wealth. The house. The savings. The family assets.

And this is true not just in America, but in Germany and Sweden, the other two countries they studied.

Based on tracking 5,000 families over two generations, it turns out family wealth determines whether a kid lives near the best schools, and whether, if they fail, there’s a childhood bedroom to come back to — which gives a kid the confidence to try something riskier and potentially more rewarding.

People who don’t have that family backstop — tend to play it safe.

The study ALSO found that most government programs that try to give people an artificial boost up the ladder don’t work. Not even in socialist countries like Sweden.

In fact, what the researchers recommend, if a country is really serious about creating a land of opportunity, isn’t more social services, or more government checks, but more private assets. To quote a similar study from 30 years ago — “income feeds peoples’ stomachs, assets change their minds.” Or as I like to say, anybody can take a stumble. But if you have a little wealth stored up, at least you’ll fall on your assets. I’ll apologize for that later.

Dave Ross Commentary:

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave Ross

Image: From left, Chris Sullivan, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien stand together in the KIRO Newsradi...

MyNorthwest Staff

Dave and Colleen’s final ‘SMN:’ KIRO colleagues, politicians say their goodbyes

"Seattle's Morning News" on KIRO Newsradio will soon have a new sound. On Thursday, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien will host their last show together after a decade of co-hosting.

2 years ago

Classical literature on bookshelves. (Photo by Richard Baker / In Pictures via Getty Images)...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross as you’ve never heard him before: ‘I like fat books and I can’t deny’

"This song, inspired by one of my first interviews when I started my talk show, which was Sir Mix-A-Lot," Dave Ross said.

2 years ago

national debt...

Dave Ross

‘Don’t cut a cent:’ Dave Ross on why the national debt never gets under control

The national debt now exceeds $36 trillion, and every president says it has to be under control. And yet, it never is.

2 years ago

voters hormone...

Dave Ross

Ross: Voters weren’t just voting for change, they were voting for a hormone

The more I read the post-election analysis, the more I’m convinced voters weren’t just voting for a change – they were voting for a hormone.

2 years ago

ross o'brien - Seattle's Morning News...

Frank Sumrall

Dave Ross, Colleen O’Brien departing after co-hosting ‘Seattle’s Morning News’ for a decade

Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien, the co-hosts of "Seattle's Morning News" on KIRO Newsradio are both leaving the show.

2 years ago

election day...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross: Election Day and Decision Day are two separate things

Tomorrow is Election Day – that’s what the calendar says. But there are two problems with the term "Election Day."

2 years ago

You can be anything you want to be, or can you?