JAKE AND SPIKE

‘She deserves every dollar’: Spike praises fired SPD employee after $875K vaccine mandate settlement

Jul 24, 2025, 5:44 PM

Marina Shinderuk, who was terminated from the Seattle Police Department (SPD) after her 14-year career, has secured a $875,000 settlement from the City of Seattle for her refusal to receive the COVID-19 vaccine.

KIRO host Spike O’Neill commended Shinderuk for her determination.

“She tried every possible way to give them a workable solution to maintain in the department, and they just said ‘No thanks,'” Spike said on “The Jake and Spike Show” on KIRO Newsradio. “I don’t know if they were trying to make an example out of her as a supervisor, saying, ‘You’re either going to go by the rules, or you’re gone,’ but I think that has a lot to do with why she won the settlement. She deserves every dollar.”

Fired SPD employee claims she wasn’t given accommodations

The City of Seattle provided accommodations for unvaccinated individuals during that time, including social distancing, masks, and routine testing. Shinderuk claimed that she was not allowed these accommodations, which ultimately led to her termination.

“She’s a single mother with three kids, and COVID rolls around. She applies for and receives a religious exemption, then shortly after, they’re not honoring the exemption,” KIRO host Jake Skorheim said. “Unceremoniously, she gets fired, jobs gone after 14 years.”

Shinderuk offered a variety of arrangements she could make for her employer in place of receiving the vaccine, including remote work, relocation, and enhanced safety protocols.

“She was bending over backwards to try and accommodate what she believed was important to her employers,” Jake said. “She wants to keep her job, but also needs to make sure she can support her family. She smartly lawyered up and decided to sue.”

Shinderuk began her career as a telecommunicator and was promoted to police communications supervisor in 2019. She was later terminated from her position in 2021 for her refusal to receive the COVID-19 vaccine.

“A 14-year veteran who has dedicated her skill sets to making sure this city is a safe place to live,” Spike said. “A poster woman for how you want a civil employee to be and behave.”

Shinderuk’s attorney dubbed the settlement a “big win for the citizens of Washington State,” according to KOMO News. Her attorney also cited the City of Seattle’s failure to accommodate her religious exemption as grounds for the settlement.

“I wonder how much she was originally suing for. It’s a settlement, and that’s always a business decision. She doesn’t want to keep fighting it,” Jake said. “Maybe she was going for $2 million, but they settled and she got paid, which is great.”

The World Health Organization reported a cumulative total of more than 7 million COVID-19 deaths worldwide, and more than 1.2 million inside the United States as of this reporting.

“This is a mixed bag for me, because I felt that the state had a right to mandate these requirements for employment,” Spike said. “In hindsight, they were trying to make the best of an unknown situation that was evolving in horrific directions. We forget how horrific it was back then, and states were making decisions based on the most informed science at the time.”

Listen to the full conversation below.

Listen to “The Jake and Spike Show” weekdays from noon to 3 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Jake and Spike

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It feels bad actory to me’: Jake doubts the tech outages were a coincidence as Microsoft CEO promises resilience

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said last week’s global outage showed how much the world depends on his company’s services.

10 hours ago

starbucks uw boycott...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Where does he think all the money comes from?’: Jake blasts Rep. Shaun Scott’s support for UW Starbucks boycott

Explore Jake Skorheim's response to Rep. Shaun Scott's stance on the UW Starbucks boycott and its implications for students and workers.

21 hours ago

...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Two guys who are failing upwards’: KIRO hosts wonder whether Reykdal is coming for Ferguson’s job

State schools Superintendent Chris Reykdal said he won't run for a fourth term, and Jake and Tim suspect he's looking at a bigger office.

1 day ago

I-638 Attorney General Nick Brown Law firm Seattle WA...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘He did it in bad faith’: Rantz challenges AG Brown’s handling of I-638 defense, Seattle schools’ legal action

Jason Rantz criticized Washington Attorney General Nick Brown’s handling of the legal defense of Initiative 638, arguing that Brown undermined the voter-approved measure.

2 days ago

James Bond robert pattinson...

Jake Skorheim

Jake: I don’t like the new James Bond pick, but my wife sure does

I told my wife that the new James Bond is the guy who played Edward Cullen in "Twilight." Suddenly, she wants to see the Bond movies. For the first time. Ever.

3 days ago

Ballard food delivery...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘You do it casually, and you’re going to get savaged’: KIRO hosts weigh Ballard’s new local challenger to DoorDash

A new food delivery service started by Ballard restaurant owners aims to cut out the big apps.

8 days ago

‘She deserves every dollar’: Spike praises fired SPD employee after $875K vaccine mandate settlement