‘Jim, what are you talking about?’: Curley challenges Jim Walsh’s claim that WA is a libertarian-leaning purple state
Nov 17, 2026, 1:50 PM
KIRO Newsradio host John Curley challenged Washington State Republican Party Chair Jim Walsh’s description of Washington as a libertarian-leaning purple state, arguing that voters’ support for Democrats and bigger government tells a different story.
On “The John Curley Show,” Curley played recordings of Walsh outlining the Republican Party’s future and describing Washington’s political identity.
“Washington state is neither a blue nor a red state,” Walsh stated in the recording. “It’s a purple state that leans kind of libertarian, and it really, really, really doesn’t like Donald Trump. And we’ve known this for a decade.”
Curley wasn’t convinced.
“OK, we know they hate Donald Trump. I don’t think we’re anywhere near a libertarian state,” Curley said. “We probably aren’t even top 30 on the list for libertarian. Jim, what are you talking about?”
Curley also disputed Seattle Public Schools Superintendent Ben Shuldiner’s separate description of Seattle as libertarian, arguing that both men were applying the label to a place whose policies don’t fit it.
Curley questions the purple-state argument
Curley cited the state’s capital gains tax, millionaires tax, and limited charter school options as evidence against Walsh’s characterization. He also argued that Washington voters have not embraced the smaller-government message Republicans have offered.
“If it’s about transparency and if it’s about smaller, limited government, nobody’s buying that,” Curley said. “They love bigger government, and they want it to solve more problems because, for some reason, somebody has told them that the government can make things more affordable.”
Walsh emphasizes principles, Curley questions the electoral results
In another recording, Walsh argued that Republicans should continue promoting limited and transparent government, stronger public schools, safer neighborhoods, and what he considers more rational taxes.
“We’ll continue to stick to our principles, and we will tell the truth,” Walsh stated.
Curley acknowledged the difficulty of campaigning under Trump’s political shadow.
“The giant shadow of Donald Trump is cast across every single envelope of every single person voting in the state of Washington,” Curley said.
But he also questioned the party’s ability to recruit candidates who can defeat established officeholders.
“I think the other struggle is you don’t have good candidates, or you can’t get a candidate,” Curley said.
He argued that challenging incumbents requires giving voters a compelling reason to abandon someone they already know, rather than simply repeating criticisms of Democratic leadership.
“Well, listen, everybody had heard this over and over again, but nobody went with it, Jim,” Curley said. “That’s the problem.”
Walsh, meanwhile, predicted that Democratic economic policies would create an opening for Republicans. He accused Gov. Bob Ferguson and Senate leadership of damaging Washington’s technology industry.
“They’re chasing the tech sector out of the state, and that’s going to help us shine a light again,” Walsh stated. “Tell the truth about the disastrous economic policies of Inslee to Ferguson to Peterson.”
Superintendent’s Seattle description draws another objection
Producer Joe Wallace introduced a recording of Shuldiner offering his own assessment of Seattle.
“My understanding of Seattle is that it’s not really liberal,” Shuldiner stated. “It’s that it’s libertarian.”
Shuldiner elaborated that people seemed able to do what they wanted without rules consistently applying. He connected that criticism to his desire for accountability in the school district.
“I think we have to be really thoughtful about what we need to do as a school district to say we care about our children and we’re going to hold people accountable to get those kids across that finish line,” Shuldiner stated.
Curley supported the superintendent’s emphasis on getting results but rejected his definition of libertarianism.
“Okay, there are rules,” Curley said. “The rules are: you live your life, I live my life.”
He argued that respecting individual freedom does not mean disregarding other people’s rights or abandoning accountability.
“I’ll respect your rights,” Curley said. “You respect mine. You don’t bother me. I won’t bother you.”
Curley sees no quick Republican comeback
Curley returned to Walsh’s position, arguing that blaming the party chair alone overlooks the challenges Republicans face in Washington.
“You can’t win when you got Trump hanging over everybody,” Curley said. “That’s tough for Jim to have to come up against.”
He described a potential scenario in which higher taxes and economic difficulties eventually cause voters to reconsider their support for Democratic leadership. But he presented that as a hoped-for political turning point, not an outcome already underway.
Ultimately, Curley remained skeptical that the Republican turnaround he described would arrive soon.
“I don’t know that’s going to be happening for a while,” Curley said.
Watch the full discussion in the video above.
Listen to The John Curley Show weekday afternoons from 3 – 7 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.



