JAKE AND SPIKE

Seattle’s $30M CHOP verdict: Breaking down how wrongful death damages are calculated

Mar 8, 2026, 5:00 AM

In January, a jury ordered the City of Seattle to pay more than $30 million over the unsolved, fatal shooting of a teenager, Antonio Mays Jr., at the “Capitol Hill Occupied Protest” (CHOP) zone.

Seattle was ordered to pay $4 million to Mays’ estate and $26 million to his father, Antonio Mays Sr. The financial resolution prompted KIRO host Jake Skorheim to investigate the inner workings of how the parties settle on the amount of money to be paid.

“I’m not trying to be grim towards the or negative towards the people who have perished, but I’m just saying that’s tax dollars. How do they decide on that money?” Skorheim said on “The Jake and Spike Show.” “How does the city start that conversation, and how do they make assessments like, what is a person’s life worth?”

“We’ve got to remember that the final decision maker of the value of a claim is a jury, right? So both sides are trying to predict what a jury might do in the case, and that’s where you start as far as valuing the claim at hand,” Chris Davis, founder of Davis Law Group, answered.

According to Davis, several components contribute to the overall damages: Economic damages, which typically refer to the medical bills, past and future, and wage losses, and non-economic damages, which are commonly referred to as pain and suffering, including humiliation, mental anguish, emotional distress, and loss of enjoyment of life.

“So between those two components, each side is trying to predict how might a jury see this claim? What might a jury do as far as money damages? That’s the start of each side valuing the claim and then deciding at some point to come together and try to negotiate a settlement to avoid a trial,” Davis added. “In these two [CHOP] cases, they both perished, and so then it would have just been their families that you would be obviously representing.”

“These, to me, are headline-making cases. I mean, those are huge judgments; it was at $30.5 million in damages on this judgment,” Jake stated. “What is somebody going to get? Is it all dependent on injury and just how much you can argue?”

“It really comes down to the injuries. In a wrongful death case, for instance, there’s pre-death pain and suffering that’s compensable under the law,” Davis said. “So a lot of times, if you’ve got a client or a victim that experienced extreme pain, terror, fright, that’s a separate damage component on the jury verdict form, so the lawyers will try to assess, okay, what is several minutes worth of pain is before you die, right? And there’s no formula involved. Every case is unique.”

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to “The Jake and Spike Show” weekdays from noon to 3 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Davis Law Group is a longtime client and partner with KIRO Newsradio and Seattle Sports

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Jake and Spike

golf course...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Move on to the people who sleep in their vans’: Jake and Spike square off over scrapped Westport golf course

KIRO host Jake Skorheim called it a huge missed opportunity for Westport after the state parks commission voted to end plans for a golf course.

3 hours ago

tip...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Come hate us’: Jake and Spike divided over pub adding 20% tip for bad tippers

A North Carolina pub that adds a 20% gratuity to the bills of repeat bad tippers divided KIRO hosts Jake Skorheim and Spike O’Neill.

3 hours ago

wa income tax businesses...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘They will stop at nothing to get it’: Jake criticizes Sen. Pedersen’s corporate income tax idea for WA businesses

Jake Skorheim argues against Jamie Pedersen's corporate income tax for Washington businesses, raising concerns over its impact on the state's economy.

1 day ago

school employeesWashington Superintendent of Public Instruction Chris Reykdal...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Why does it have to be left v. lefter?’: Jake challenges WA’s political options as Reykdal considers higher office

Jake Skorheim examines Washington's political landscape as Reykdal eyes higher office, exploring implications for future elections.

3 days ago

Jimothy Seattle City Council Rob Saka...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It’s still a very bad idea’: Jake and Spike mock illuminated Jimothy statue with impression

A discussion about an illuminated Jimothy raccoon statue turned into a mock Seattle City Council meeting where Spike O’Neill impersonated Councilmember Rob Saka.

3 days ago

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It feels bad actory to me’: Jake doubts the tech outages were a coincidence as Microsoft CEO promises resilience

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said last week’s global outage showed how much the world depends on his company’s services.

4 days ago

Seattle’s $30M CHOP verdict: Breaking down how wrongful death damages are calculated