JOHN CURLEY

Is Seattle’s soda tax actually making people healthier?

Jul 9, 2018, 4:52 PM

soda tax...

A sign indicating higher prices of sugary drinks due to Seattle's soda tax. (Dyer Oxley, MyNorthwest)

(Dyer Oxley, MyNorthwest)

It’s not entirely surprising that Seattle’s soda tax has been raising money at a rapid rate, now totaling approximately $4.5 million. Nor is it a shock that the 1.75 cents per ounce has caused a decline in soda sales at stores and distributors.

What KIRO Radio’s John Curley wants to know if anybody’s actually getting healthier.

“Will people buy less sugary drinks if you raise the price? Yes,” Curley said. “Will they get thinner and will this do anything about obesity? The answer to that is no. There’s no evidence that shows people won’t consume some other type of sugary thing. They might not drink a soda, but then they’ll go ahead and drink a milkshake.”

RELATED: Initiative to stop soda, grocery tax gets big support, likely to make Nov ballot

The money is set to pay for healthy-food programs, community-college scholarships, administrative costs, and early-learning programs. Part of the revenue will also be spent on studying the tax itself, and how it impacts people’s consumption behavior.

What Curley would like is for the study to specifically look at whether people are actually getting healthier, since it’s seemingly the entire thrust of the tax.

“Why don’t you get a metric? Do a test. Get 4,000 or 5,000 to make it scientifically relevant. OK, these are soda drinkers, and then the tax goes into effect. You weigh 245 pounds, you’re 5’7, and you’ve got a 41 inch waist. One year later, you’re exactly the same weight, if not heavier, because now you’re buying a Snickers bar.”

“Well then we’ll go after the Snickers bars,” joked KIRO Radio’s Tom Tangney.

There’s been an effort to implement such a tax at the state level, as well as an effort to prevent it. On January 8, a resolution to re-introduce HB 1975 was passed. It would place a tax on distributors of sugary drinks, but at 2 cents per fluid ounce, more than Seattle’s 1.75 cents per fluid ounce. Neither efforts were successful.

Those opposed recently gathered upwards of 350,000 signatures for Initiative 1634, which would bar local governments from imposing taxes on sweetened beverages.

Is the soda about more than reducing obesity?

For Tom, the soda tax is a greater good even if it doesn’t reduce obesity, considering the money being raised.

“It’s a failsafe situation, because even if you don’t get people to stop drinking, you at least are raising money for a good cause,” he said. “If you raise money for early infant education, there’s a social good that comes out of it whether we stop drinking or not. When I go into a Bartell and they have the price announcing what the soda tax is on top of it, I don’t know if that’s going to stop somebody who’s dying for a Coke.”

But Curley wants the tax to be held to the issue its proponents claim to be tackling. “Ultimately, what we’re trying to do is to have people be healthier and less obese. But they have no metric, as they never want to have a metric.”

“The thing they’re looking at is: ‘Hey, we made $4.5 million after transferring income from mostly poor minorities to the government, which will then take that and create government work jobs, like for instance, somebody handing out bananas and apples and oranges to people that don’t want them.”

“Sales are down, so people are making different choices. But are they getting thinner?”

Please follow our Community Guidelines
John Curley on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to tom and curleyTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 3pm for The John Curley Show.

John Curley

John Curley

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘One party with two jerseys’: Former Evergreen professor Bret Weinstein outlines plan to take over Libertarian Party

Bret Weinstein said his American Liberty Party aims to break the hold of the Republican and Democratic parties by taking over the Libertarian Party.

2 days ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘She went against everybody that had gotten her in there’: Curley questions Katie Wilson’s Seattle CCTV expansion

John Curley characterized Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson’s decision to expand police surveillance cameras as a break with the supporters who helped elect her.

3 days ago

I-638 WA girls sports WA transgender...

John Curley Show

‘Collide with the will of the people’: Curley questions Seattle schools’ legal action over transgender eligibility in girls’ sports

John Curley critiques the legal challenge against girls' sports eligibility for transgender athletes in Seattle.

3 days ago

Ferguson millionaires' tax...

John Curley Show

‘How much is enough?’: KIRO hosts question WA’s spending as Ferguson celebrates voters keeping millionaires’ tax

Washington voters rejected Initiative 645, keeping the state’s millionaires tax in place. Ferguson said the tax would help bring fiscal stability.

5 days ago

seattle housing build...

John Curley Show

‘I think this is a very smart move’: Curley praises Nilu Jenks’ push to make Seattle housing easier to build

Nilu Jenks aims to simplify Seattle housing development through zoning changes and faster permits, boosting the housing supply.

6 days ago

seattle public disorder...

John Curley Show

‘They aren’t accepting failure as an option’: Seattle chamber CEO contrasts San Francisco’s approach to public disorder

Seattle's chamber CEO urges leaders to learn from San Francisco's approach to public disorder for a stronger community response.

6 days ago

Is Seattle’s soda tax actually making people healthier?