KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

Butler: It’s time for food delivery apps to ‘PayUp’ in Seattle, beyond

Apr 30, 2024, 11:18 PM

Image: A biker making a food delivery biker grapples with the rain....

A biker making a food delivery biker grapples with the rain. (Photo: Getty Images)

(Photo: Getty Images)

Proposed changes to the “PayUp” ordinance in Seattle, intended to improve compensation and terms for so called “gig workers” highlights something I find interesting — and I think some people miss.

These app companies have figured out how to offload the costs of maintenance, insurance, and that ever-variable in rising cost of gas onto the employee, which is smart business. But it also puts more burden on the workers to maintain the equipment needed to do their jobs. Big tech develops and maintains the app and provides customer service. But the actual work gets done by those on the ground — the people the PayUp legislation was intended to help.

Critics focus on what seems like a “higher than minimum wage” for drivers. But when you factor in their actual costs, especially with the fuel prices we pay in Washington, food delivery is not making drivers wealthy. And I’d argue they’re not getting more than they deserve. No one is getting rich here …

… Except for UberEats and DoorDash. They’ve got the cash to throw at lobbyists. Revenues for the online food ordering sector reached $294 billion in 2021. And no one’s saying these companies can’t continue to profit. But they don’t get to offload the bulk of their costs, create a product that pressures independent restaurants to buy in to remain competitive, profit massively, and expect to basically write the laws in their favor.

More from Matt Butler: Pearl Jam’s Dark Matter among the band’s ‘best, most cohesive records’

I think these companies are missing an opportunity. Try this: Be the company that attracts more drivers and a greater share of the market by proudly advertising how much better you make things for your employees. You offer better pay, solid benefits they can actually use. And here’s a classic move you might try: undercut your competition. Lower the fees the mom-and-pop restaurants pay, or remove the $5 charge in Seattle for customers — resulting in more deliveries, and more tips for your drivers and less business for your competitors.

Ultimately, these apps are a luxury. They’re not an entitlement, and most people (with a few homebound exceptions) don’t really need them to live. They’re convenient — and convenience has a price. But they’re not a convenience for the workers — and those whose labor and time has netted billions in revenue for Silicon Valley, shouldn’t be shafted in the process of any adjustments.

Matt Butler is the producer for “KIRO Nights with Jake Skorheim” and a contributing writer to MyNorthwest.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

A photo of a Social Security card and money. (Photo: nodar77 via Envato)...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘That’s unacceptable’: Ursula criticizes Social Security uncertainty as AARP projections show funding for only 80% of promised benefits

AARP warns funding for Social Security benefits may drop to 80%, raising concerns over the program's financial stability.

24 hours ago

Denny Blaine Seattle LGBTQ...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘This is a beautiful thing’: Gee praises Seattle’s celebration of Denny Blaine Park’s LGBTQ history amid nude beach controversy

Seattle honors Denny Blaine Park's LGBTQ history after years of debate, uniting community leaders and members in celebration.

2 days ago

microsoft outage...

Luke Duecy

The Spin: Microsoft outage and how the company used PR to manage a global service disruption

A major Microsoft outage disrupted Outlook, Teams, Copilot, and other Microsoft 365 services for two days.

3 days ago

Follow @https://twitter.com/jcurleyshow...

John Curley Show

‘She went against everybody that had gotten her in there’: Curley questions Katie Wilson’s Seattle CCTV expansion

John Curley characterized Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson’s decision to expand police surveillance cameras as a break with the supporters who helped elect her.

3 days ago

Seattle Freeways tailgaters...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Turn signals, tailgaters, and the 5 most annoying drivers on Seattle freeways

I drive to work in the dark, and I’m coming down the ramp from westbound Highway 18 onto northbound I-5. Wipers going. Coffee in the cupholder. A semi is barreling down the right lane, and there’s a car in front of me on the ramp.

3 days ago

vote (2)...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘It matters’: Gee and Ursula point to 4-vote WA House race as proof every ballot counts

If you've ever thought your vote doesn't matter, KIRO hosts Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin have an example from East Pierce County.

3 days ago

Butler: It’s time for food delivery apps to ‘PayUp’ in Seattle, beyond