KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

‘I think that’s a mistake’: Jake warns CARE chief’s blunt approach won’t work with SPD

Feb 28, 2026, 5:01 AM

The Community Assisted Response and Engagement Department’s (CARE) chief, Amy Barton, has expressed displeasure with the lack of support from the Seattle Police Department (SPD).

CARE’s goal is to send out “experts” to non-emergency calls, primarily dealing with individuals suffering from mental health crises, rather than sending out SPD officers to respond.

Jake Skorheim and Spike O’Neill, co-hosts of “The Jake and Spike Show” on KIRO Newsradio, detailed Barton’s frustrations as the two departments go head-to-head in a battle over which personnel are capable of responding to the many 911 calls each day.

“You have politicians who want to push this out there as a good thing, but you also have to have the Seattle Police Department hand over what used to be part of their responsibility to the Care Bears, which they don’t really want to do,” Jake said. “They were told they had to do it, but they don’t really want to do it. [Barton’s] frustrated because she says that she’s not getting support from Seattle Police officers.”

Low-danger calls can turn violent even without criminal intent

Spike noted SPD has been trained to handle these situations for years, oftentimes solely sending out CARE members to what looks like a low-danger situation, which could take a turn for the worse if officers are not present.

“I think police come at this from a much more pragmatic and realistic perspective, understanding that while a situation may be based on a mental health crisis, there are still real dangers and threats for someone. Just because there’s no criminal intent, they still could be violent,” Spike said.

Spike believes the program could be viable, but said the two departments must work together and build on each other’s shared experiences for it to have a real shot at being an effective program.

“They’re spending a bunch of money, and have a genuine opportunity to be valuable to the community,” Spike said. “I think it’s a worthwhile program, but they have to respect the parameters, the learned experience of law enforcement communities about potential danger for these care representatives in the community. [SPD] thinks they know best about these situations, and oftentimes they do.

“I think the solution here is an acceptance that the police are going to know best, and you’re going to be called when needed,” Spike continued. “I’d rather err on the side of cautious safety, I should say, for the CARE teams. You send a couple of these folks out into a situation that they’re not ready to handle, that escalates beyond their capacity to control, and then suddenly, you’re calling for backup from a law enforcement officer, and that’s oftentimes too late.”

Jake noted Barton may be stepping on a few of SPD’s toes as she is working toward her goal.

“I think it would be smarter to try to ingratiate yourself with a long-standing, very proud department that’s already doing as good a job as they can do,” Jake said. “Given their limited resources on some of these things, also given the city’s political leaders’ inability to address the issues that they’re having to face every single day on the street, they must be very frustrated.

“I don’t think we should be disparaging them in any way. I think that’s a mistake,” he continued. “If I were advising her, I would say maybe step back a little bit. Take a kinder approach. Try to figure out how we can come alongside SPD and accompany you in a way that doesn’t step on your toes. She should ingratiate herself more than just stomping her foot.”

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to “The Jake and Spike Show” weekdays from noon to 3 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

wa girls sports i-638...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘This is going to be a mess’: Gee raises concerns about girls missing competitions under WA’s new verification rules

New verification rules in Washington raise alarms about girls missing sports competitions. Insights on I-638 and its impact.

8 hours ago

seattle katie wilson budget...

John Curley Show

‘Three cheers for Katie Wilson’: Curley praises Seattle mayor’s budget restraint, decision to expand police cameras

John Curley celebrated Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson's budget plan, emphasizing fiscal restraint while expanding police camera initiatives for community safety.

11 hours ago

KIRO Newsradio app idea...

Charlie Harger

Harger: My trillion-dollar idea for the KIRO Newsradio app

Explore Charlie Harger's innovative vision for the KIRO Newsradio app and how it could reshape your listening and gaming experience.

13 hours ago

kratom edmonds death...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘Withdrawal from kratom is horrific’: KIRO producer describes his struggle as Edmonds family pushes for sales ban

KIRO producer Andrew Lanier shares his withdrawal struggle as an Edmonds family seeks to ban kratom following their son's death.

14 hours ago

seattle superintendent ipad school...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘You are here to be the fall guy’: Gee and Ursula criticize Seattle School Board for handing school closure power to superintendent

The Seattle School Board has given Superintendent Ben Shuldiner the power to close or merge schools without a final board vote.

1 day ago

health care...

John Curley Show

‘It’s not their money’: Curley asks who will be held accountable for WA health care error that could cost $654 million

KIRO host John Curley is asking whether anyone will lose their job after a reporting error by the Washington State Health Care Authority.

1 day ago

‘I think that’s a mistake’: Jake warns CARE chief’s blunt approach won’t work with SPD