KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

‘You are here to be the fall guy’: Gee and Ursula criticize Seattle School Board for handing school closure power to superintendent

Nov 19, 2026, 6:46 PM

The Seattle School Board has given Seattle Public Schools Superintendent Ben Shuldiner the power to close or merge schools without a final board vote. KIRO host Gee Scott thinks board members are setting Shuldiner up to take the blame.

“You are here to be the fall guy. That’s what it is,” Gee said on “The Gee and Ursula Show” on KIRO Newsradio.

The board voted unanimously Wednesday to approve changes to its school closure policy, which now “places authority with the Superintendent for instructional site closures,” KOMO News reported. That removes the board’s public hearing and final vote. Shuldiner will no longer have to publicly present his reasons for closing a campus, though he still has to notify staff, affected families and board directors. The board also eliminated two waiting periods, 30 days after the superintendent’s preliminary recommendation and 14 days after his final one, that had been set aside for public review.

Board Director Joe Mizrahi said the changes won’t cut any public hearings or chances to comment. The hearings still happen, just sooner, he said. Shuldiner said the board can still block a closure with a majority vote.

Gee: ‘We’re just gonna blame it all on Ben’

Gee pointed out that board members ask voters to trust their judgment on decisions like these.

“The school board said, ‘Oh, hey everybody, we don’t want to do any decision making. We’re gonna put it all on the superintendent,’” Gee said. “So then that way, when the schools, which ones decide to close, y’all can’t say it was us. We’re just gonna blame it all on Ben.”

He has been impressed with Shuldiner since the superintendent appeared on the show, but now he wonders how long Shuldiner will last.

“I like this Ben. I think this Ben is a great leader,” Gee said. “I wonder how long he’s gonna be here. Well, clock’s ticking.”

Ursula: ‘Leadership requires accountability’

KIRO host Ursula Reutin has also praised Shuldiner for his listening tour when he arrived, and his transparency during labor negotiations, which she believes helped prevent a teachers’ strike. But she questioned why the board would give up its role.

“Is this board so feckless that its members would rather let the superintendent take all the heat than face angry parents themselves?” Ursula asked.

She acknowledged that the district’s last attempt at school closures went in circles before the previous superintendent resigned, and she understood the board’s desire for a more decisive process.

Still, she wasn’t convinced.

“Leadership requires accountability,” Ursula said. “The school board doesn’t get to hand off that responsibility only to him. For these latest moves, I’m giving the Seattle School District a failing grade.”

A reporter at a family meeting

Two days before the vote, Shuldiner met with about 80 families Monday night at Highland Park Elementary about a plan to merge Sanislo Elementary into Highland Park.

West Seattle Blog editor Tracy Record was there to cover the meeting. Families had forwarded the district’s messages to the blog and asked her to come. A district official told Record the meeting wasn’t open to the media and that she needed to leave, according to her account. She refused.

Shuldiner then pointed her out to the room.

“There is a member of the media in this room. She’s sitting right over there. I don’t know if that’s going to make people feel safe or not,” Shuldiner told the families. “It’s up to families. This is your meeting. It’s your space. I want you to feel comfortable.”

Several parents objected out loud and spoke up for Record, and she stayed.

Record said no one was asked for personal or sensitive information, and no one offered any. In an editor’s note, she wrote that getting accurate, impartial information to more people sooner is actually a “safer” and better thing.

Ursula called Shuldiner’s handling of the moment appalling.

“That’s not transparency,” she said. “That feeds into this dangerous narrative that journalists are somehow the enemy of the people.”

Gee asked to hear the clip again and came away with a different view.

“I respect how he went about that,” Gee said. “The people said, ‘Hey, we asked for her to be here,’ and he says, ‘OK.’ So I just want to say I love the way he handled that.”

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to Gee and Ursula on “The Gee and Ursula Show” weekday mornings from 9 a.m. to 12 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Gee and Ursula Show

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

seattle superintendent ipad school...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘You are here to be the fall guy’: Gee and Ursula criticize Seattle School Board for handing school closure power to superintendent

The Seattle School Board has given Superintendent Ben Shuldiner the power to close or merge schools without a final board vote.

28 minutes ago

health care...

John Curley Show

‘It’s not their money’: Curley asks who will be held accountable for WA health care error that could cost $654 million

KIRO host John Curley is asking whether anyone will lose their job after a reporting error by the Washington State Health Care Authority.

5 hours ago

turkey prep...

Charlie Harger

Big turkey? You may need to start defrosting it today. Here’s your Thanksgiving 2026 schedule by weight

Check your freezer. If there's a big turkey in there, it may need to start defrosting today.

8 hours ago

school employeesWashington Superintendent of Public Instruction Chris Reykdal...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘Why does it have to be left v. lefter?’: Jake challenges WA’s political options as Reykdal considers higher office

Jake Skorheim examines Washington's political landscape as Reykdal eyes higher office, exploring implications for future elections.

10 hours ago

Jimothy Seattle City Council Rob Saka...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It’s still a very bad idea’: Jake and Spike mock illuminated Jimothy statue with impression

A discussion about an illuminated Jimothy raccoon statue turned into a mock Seattle City Council meeting where Spike O’Neill impersonated Councilmember Rob Saka.

11 hours ago

seattle publics schools reporter superintendent...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Families asked a reporter to cover their school closure meeting. Seattle Public Schools tried to throw her out

The Seattle School Board gave the superintendent, Ben Shuldiner, even more control over that process and dropped the requirement that he publicly explain why a school needs to close.

12 hours ago

‘You are here to be the fall guy’: Gee and Ursula criticize Seattle School Board for handing school closure power to superintendent