KIRO NEWSRADIO

The likelihood of California, Oregon and Washington seceding

Nov 23, 2016, 5:45 AM | Updated: Oct 11, 2024, 9:55 am

Washington seceding...

After SDonald Trump was elected president in the November 2016 election, small movements were started in California, Oregon and Washington to secede from the United States. (AP)

(AP)

Since the election, there’s been talk of Oregon, California and Washington seceding, breaking off from the rest of the country to form their own nation. Or even to join up with Canada.

In California, the notion was titled “CalExit,” a take on Brexit. On Monday, the Yes California Independence Campaign took the first step to try and make CalExit a reality. They submitted a proposed ballot measure to the state attorney general’s office, and they hope to start gathering signatures so Californians can vote on the secession in 2018.

Talking to kids about Donald Trump’s election

There have also been movements for Oregon and Washington seceding.

What are the chances of any of this actually happening? University of Washington law professor Hugh Spitzer says slim to none. I asked him about the steps the states would have to take to secede.

“There is not a good rationale under international law for California, Washington, and Oregon to secede from the United States on the grounds that they’re oppressed,” Spitzer said. “All that’s happened so far is they lost an election.”

“Perhaps they could have a referendum and vote to secede to form a new country,” he said. “But if people voted for that, maybe by 50 or 60 percent, that’s probably all you’d ever get, then you’d have to talk to the United States and say, ‘Would you like to let us secede?’ Of course, the last time that happened, in 1861, the United States said ‘No! We’re an indivisible country and we’re not going to allow that to happen.'”

“Then we would be stuck with staying in the United States or being willing to fight about it,” Spitzer notes. “The last time that happened in the 1860’s there were more than 600,000 people killed in the armies of the north and south. I’m not sure there’s going to be much stomach for that.”

The people in these states who want to secede tend to be liberal pacifists, so a war would probably be out of the question.

“War is not the only approach,” Spitzer said. “It might be conceivable that there would be massive, permanent, civil disobedience such as massive refusal to pay income tax to the national government, massive, say, not using the postal service anymore. Basically, people would no longer use the national government for anything within these three states. That’s actually much more likely in a fairly peaceful country like ours.”

Alternative to Washington seceding

Professor Spitzer believes the country would be much more successful if it were split into smaller sections, like Canadian provinces.

“What makes much more sense is to re-divide the United States into 13 states, just like we originally had,” he said. “With much more of the government responsibility being allocated to each of the 13 states, which would be larger, which would have more influence together, just like the provinces in Canada fundamentally have much more influence over national policy.”

“I think the federal government should do much less, particularly outside of defense and international trade and foreign relations,” Spitzer said. “The states should have a lot more responsibility. I think that we could accomplish all the benefits of secession by staying in an economic union with the rest of the United States, and in a defense union, but having a lot more responsibility sent back to the states, which is where it originally was back in 1787.”

If the idea of Washington seceding sounds ridiculous, it has worked in other places, however.

“When Norway left the federation with Sweden in 1905 they had a vote of the people to secede and it received 99.95 percent of the vote to leave Sweden,” Spitzer said. “So it was pretty hard under those circumstances for Sweden to say, ‘Oh, you still have to stay.'”

That said, I don’t know if there’s anything that 99 percent of Americans would agree on.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

FILE - A pair of North Atlantic right whales interact at the surface of Cape Cod Bay, March 27, 202...

Associated Press

Rare North Atlantic right whale population drops, alarming scientists

PORTLAND, Maine (AP) — The population of one of the world’s rarest whales has fallen after trending upward in recent years, worrying scientists who fear the animal could still be at risk of extinction. The North Atlantic right whale now numbers 382 animals, according to a consortium of scientists that released its annual population estimate […]

1 hour ago

Associated Press

UN-backed talks consider possible rules on lethal autonomous weapons

GENEVA (AP) — Killer robots and drones come up for a reckoning this week as government envoys rev up a discussion and could decide whether to launch negotiations toward setting rules for use of the deadly machines — or not. Pope Leo XIV, the U.N. chief and advocacy groups cast the issue as an existential […]

3 hours ago

A person looks at a flight information board at LaGuardia Airport in New York, Friday, Nov. 13, 202...

Associated Press

Questions swirl around FAA’s new SMART AI system, though officials say no link to ground stop

The airline ground stop that wreaked havoc on travel since Friday was not related to the FAA’s new, $875 million AI-powered system the agency is rolling out to help predict problems in the sky, according to government officials and the artificial intelligence company behind the technology. But the timing of the ground stop, so close […]

4 hours ago

FILE - The Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., head of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, s...

Associated Press

Handwritten draft of MLK’s ‘I Have a Dream’ speech to go on display before it’s sold at auction

ATLANTA (AP) — Words scrawled in blue pen — and others scratched out — give an intimate peek into the writing of what would become the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr.’s most famous speech. Delivered Aug. 28, 1963, from the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, the “I Have a Dream” speech reflects on the shameful […]

6 hours ago

President Donald Trump speaks before signing an executive order in the Oval Office of the White Hou...

Associated Press

Trump’s Asia reset: Deals in Manila and Shenzhen, then a rare nuclear summit with Xi and Putin

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump is preparing to depart for Asia on Monday, turning his focus to economic deals and historic three-way nuclear talks with Russia and China as his administration adjusts to a new political reality in Washington. Trump’s departure comes after the often-omnipresent president had remained largely out of public sight for […]

6 hours ago

Visitors to the Steven F. Udvar-Hazy Center observation tower watch an airplane prepare to land at ...

Associated Press

AAA forecasts another busy — but not quite as busy — Thanksgiving travel week

FORT COLLINS, Colo. (AP) — Pricey plane tickets and expensive gasoline are expected to keep some Americans from traveling this Thanksgiving, but not enough to make much difference in airport security lines and highway traffic, AAA said Monday. The auto club federation predicted that 81.5 million people would travel at least 50 miles (80 kilometers) […]

6 hours ago

The likelihood of California, Oregon and Washington seceding