MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Controversial data privacy bill dies in Olympia

Apr 18, 2019, 10:07 AM

facial recognition security camera...

(Pexels)

(Pexels)

A controversial bill related to data privacy and facial recognition technology failed to make a key deadline in the Washington State Legislature Wednesday, and at least for now, is dead.

RELATED: ACLU says data privacy bill is not consumer friendly
RELATED: Facebook shared your data again

In theory, the bill proposed to allow people to contact companies and ask what information they have on them. People could then ask the company to delete such data.

But it’s not so simple according to the ACLU, which argued that the state bill was not what it seemed.

“Unfortunately, the reality and the marketing around this bill are two very different things,” claimed Shankar Narayan, technology and liberty project director with the ACLU.

At one point during the amendment process for the bill, Microsoft, Amazon, Comcast, and the Association of Washington Businesses sat down with a handful of lawmakers behind closed doors, reportedly to cobble together a version of the bill that would be palatable in both the House and Senate.

That in turn led to claims from the ACLU that tech companies were being permitted to draft the very legislation that was meant to curtail their ability to collect consumer data.

“The first problem is that it was written by the technology companies themselves,” said Narayan. “And it was stacked up with loopholes so that a company that holds your data can override your consent around that data.”

The bill also carried a measure that allowed facial recognition technology in any public place, provided a placard denotes that the technology is in use. Essentially, walking into a space or building with that placard would have been akin to giving consent to the technology’s use.

According to a report from the Everett Herald, that was a “nonstarter” for many in the House Democratic Caucus.

The bill was sponsored by Democratic Sen. Reuven Carlyle.

“We built alignment that well-crafted, strong #dataprivacy is imperative to consumers and society,” he Tweeted out Wednesday, shortly after the House failed to pass the legislation.

Back when it passed through the state Senate by a 46-1 margin, Carlyle argued that the bill was a necessity for bringing the state’s privacy laws up to date.

“This bill carefully, responsibly takes the best practices from Europe, California and other states to build a data privacy regulatory framework that will help set a standard and lead the nation in bringing our data privacy laws into the 21st century,” he said in a March news release.

Others had argued that it didn’t go far enough in protecting the data of Washington’s consumers.

Carlyle noted Wednesday that he and fellow sponsors of the bill remain “committed” to pushing forward on it again in the 2020 legislative session.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest News

A photo of a medical examination room. (Photo: Mint_Images via Envato)...

MyNorthwest Staff

New emergency, urgent care centers coming to Issaquah, Puyallup and Lake City

Virginia Mason Franciscan Health expands urgent care access in Issaquah and beyond, enhancing community health services.

1 hour ago

ballard...

Frank Lenzi

Seattle man with attempted child rape conviction accused of Ballard attack

A Seattle man convicted of trying to rape his 10-year-old cousin more than 25 years ago, is now accused of attacking a woman in Ballard.

2 hours ago

Fiona...

PATRICK AFTOORA-ORSAGOS and JOHN SEEWER, The Associated Press

Cincinnati Zoo’s famed Fiona the hippo dies days after eating a visitor’s hat

Fiona, the hippo whose premature birth and fight for survival at the Cincinnati Zoo turned her into a global sensation nearly a decade ago.

2 hours ago

Tacoma St. Joseph strike...

Frank Lenzi

Tentative deal averts strike at Tacoma’s St. Joseph Medical Center

A tentative agreement has averted a planned three-day strike by more than 225 health care workers at St. Joseph Medical Center in Tacoma.

3 hours ago

carfentanil...

MyNorthwest Staff

Puyallup man gets 5 years for shipment containing carfentanil, 100x stronger than fentanyl

A Puyallup man was sentenced to 60 months in prison for possession of controlled substances 100 times more powerful than fentanyl and his intent to distribute.

3 hours ago

Noble Bear Coffee...

Frank Lenzi

Noble Bear Coffee opens in Purdy at former bikini barista location

Noble Bear Coffee, a family-friendly drive-thru coffee stand in Purdy, celebrated its grand opening Thursday at 13716 Purdy Dr. NW.

4 hours ago

Controversial data privacy bill dies in Olympia