MYNORTHWEST POLITICS

Are there legal consequences for politicians who lie even after they’ve been caught lying?

Sep 26, 2024, 2:14 PM

politicians lie...

New York City Mayor Eric Adams exits Gracie Mansion on September 26, 2024 in New York City. (Photo: Stephanie Keith, Getty Images)

(Photo: Stephanie Keith, Getty Images)

New York City Mayor Eric Adams was indicted Thursday on federal charges for taking illegal campaign contributions and bribes from foreign nationals in exchange for favors that included helping Turkish officials bypass a fire safety inspection for a new diplomatic tower in the city.

These contributions and bribes included lavish overseas trips.

On Thursday morning, Adams said he won’t resign, causing KIRO Newsradio host Dave Ross to question whether or not there are any legal consequences for politicians who continue to lie even after they’ve been caught lying.

More from KIRO Newsradio: Homeless encampment returns to Seattle’s Highland Park neighborhood

Short answer, according to former Washington Attorney General Rob McKenna, is no, although it has been tried.

“Washington State and the U.S. Congress tried when they passed the Stolen Valor Act in 2005, which criminalized lying about receiving military honors,” McKenna said on “Seattle’s Morning News.” “Those laws didn’t stick. The Supreme Court struck down the Stolen Valor Act in 2012, finding that it violated the First Amendment, which essentially means that the First Amendment protects the right of politicians to engage in false political speech.”

One lawyer is bringing a criminal case against Donald Trump and J.D. Vance on behalf of spreading false rumors that Haitians immigrants are eating dogs and cats.

“People are wondering why there are no consequences for that, either to them or to the platforms that amplify this lie,” Ross said to McKenna.

“It comes back to the First Amendment. I mean, it would be hard to find someone liable for repeating a rumor that someone else started unless you repeat it knowing that it’s false and with actual malice,” McKenna responded. “In other words, you might have a defamation claim if an individual was defamed. But notice that Vance and Trump aren’t naming any individual immigrants who allegedly ate their neighbor’s pets.”

McKenna described one of Trump’s M.O.s as taking a statement and making the claim even more vague.

“He’ll say something like, ‘Well, I heard that’ or ‘You may have heard that’ or ‘It’s been said,’ and that’s really hard to curtail through any kind of legal action,” McKenna added.

More from Dave Ross: Enough of the broken muffler noise from motorcycles

The difference between this and actual defamation is the person in question has to know the statement is false before propagating it.

“The fact that Trump and Vance are repeating disproven rumors and stories doesn’t make them criminally liable,” McKenna said. “If someone acts on those rumors by calling in a bomb threat or phoning in a physical threat against an individual, those people are liable, but spreading rumors is not a criminal offense.”

Frank Sumrall is a content editor at MyNorthwest. You can read his stories here and you can email him here.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

MyNorthwest Politics

seattle city hall budget residents...

KIRO Newsradio staff

Seattle City Council passes budget 7-2, including $350M for affordable housing

The Seattle City Council has passed its 2027-28 budget with a vote of 7-2.

6 hours ago

seattle council president...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘I just want my kid to be able to walk to school’: Seattle council president says City Hall needs to get back to basics

Seattle City Council President Joy Hollingsworth said the city has drifted away from the basic services people expect from city government.

8 hours ago

port of tacoma...

Brooke Griffin, KIRO 7 News

Tacoma council adopts tough budget with 100 job cuts and new police hires

Tacoma Mayor Anders Ibsen said their main goal was to address a $40 million deficit, while also giving the community what it needs.

2 days ago

WIAA transgender I-638 girls sports...

Frank Lenzi

WIAA prepares for Washington girls’ sports law as I-638 takes effect Dec. 3

A law restricting participation in girls' sports at schools to biological females takes effect Dec. 3, and the WIAA said it's working to ensure compliance.

2 days ago

Tacoma detention center...

Julia Dallas

‘We’re coming after ICE’: Randall, Jayapal vow oversight after Tacoma detention center sold for $453M

Rep. Emily Randall is fighting to conduct oversight after the GEO Group sold the Tacoma Detention Center to the U.S. government.

2 days ago

Mayor Wilson budget...

Luke Duecy

‘I am disappointed’: Seattle mayor warns city council budget changes could create future deficit

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson is warning that changes proposed by the city council to the city's next two-year budget could leave Seattle facing a deficit.

2 days ago

Are there legal consequences for politicians who lie even after they’ve been caught lying?