MYNORTHWEST POLITICS

Gov. Ferguson wins appeal: WA AG’s Office cleared to probe Catholic Church sex abuse cover-up allegations

Mar 3, 2026, 11:10 AM

wa income tax ferguson...

A photo of Washington Governor Bob Ferguson. (Photo: Bob Ferguson for Governor)

(Photo: Bob Ferguson for Governor)

In a unanimous decision that could have far-reaching implications for religious institutions across the state, the Washington State Court of Appeals ruled Monday that the Attorney General’s Office has the authority to investigate whether the Catholic Church used charitable funds to cover up decades of alleged child sexual abuse by clergy.

The ruling reverses a lower court decision that had blocked the investigation, marking a significant legal victory for Governor Bob Ferguson, who launched the probe in 2023 while serving as Attorney General.

“As a Catholic, the church must do the right thing and engage in a public accounting of how the church handles allegations of child sex abuse,” Ferguson said in a statement. “This ruling is an important win for transparency. I am asking church leaders to reflect and pray about this unanimous court decision and stop fighting this investigation.”

Three-judge panel rejects church’s argument for categorical exemption

At the heart of the case was a dispute over Washington’s charitable trust act and whether religious corporations are exempt from state oversight. The Corporation of the Catholic Archbishop of Seattle — the civil entity representing the Archdiocese in western Washington — argued it was categorically exempt from the Attorney General’s subpoena power under a provision shielding religious organizations from the definition of “trustee.”

The three-judge panel, in an opinion authored by Judge Ian Birk, rejected that categorical approach. While acknowledging that the legislature had reasonable grounds for treating religious organizations differently to avoid government interference with faith and doctrine, the court held that such exemptions cannot shield evidence of criminal or tortious conduct.

“Constitutional religious protections do not provide churches with absolute immunity to engage in tortious conduct,” the court wrote, citing prior Washington Supreme Court precedent. The opinion emphasized that the state may investigate “whether criminal or tortious conduct has occurred, including sexual abuse by clergy.”

The Attorney General’s original subpoena sought records dating back to 1940 regarding clergy “accused or suspected of sexual abuse or sexual misconduct.” It also requested documents related to discipline, reassignments, communications with law enforcement, settlements with victims, and financial records.

The court cited examples from the investigation’s origins, including one priest who joined the church in 1958 and “perpetrated decades of abuse.” According to the Attorney General’s filings, the Archdiocese knew of this priest’s conduct but “repeatedly transferred him to new parishes,” allowed him to remain in ministry, and continued providing him a monthly stipend.

The ruling draws on the court’s analysis in Woods v. Seattle’s Union Gospel Mission, which established that statutory exemptions for religious organizations must be interpreted coextensively with the constitutional protections that justify them, no broader.

The case now returns to King County Superior Court, where a judge must determine the precise boundaries of what documents the Archdiocese must produce. The investigation cannot extend to second-guessing religious decisions about faith and doctrine, the appeals court cautioned, but it can demand evidence relevant to determining whether criminal or tortious acts occurred.

Ferguson, who personally attended oral arguments in the trial court before his election as governor, noted that similar investigations in Maryland and Illinois revealed far more credibly accused abusers than the Church had voluntarily disclosed.

The Archdiocese has not indicated whether it will seek further review from the Washington Supreme Court.

Manda Factor is the host of “Seattle’s Morning News” on KIRO Newsradio. Follow Manda on X and email her here. 

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest Politics

seattle city hall budget residents...

KIRO Newsradio staff

Seattle City Council passes budget 7-2, including $350M for affordable housing

The Seattle City Council has passed its 2027-28 budget with a vote of 7-2.

2 days ago

seattle council president...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘I just want my kid to be able to walk to school’: Seattle council president says City Hall needs to get back to basics

Seattle City Council President Joy Hollingsworth said the city has drifted away from the basic services people expect from city government.

2 days ago

port of tacoma...

Brooke Griffin, KIRO 7 News

Tacoma council adopts tough budget with 100 job cuts and new police hires

Tacoma Mayor Anders Ibsen said their main goal was to address a $40 million deficit, while also giving the community what it needs.

4 days ago

WIAA transgender I-638 girls sports...

Frank Lenzi

WIAA prepares for Washington girls’ sports law as I-638 takes effect Dec. 3

A law restricting participation in girls' sports at schools to biological females takes effect Dec. 3, and the WIAA said it's working to ensure compliance.

4 days ago

Tacoma detention center...

Julia Dallas

‘We’re coming after ICE’: Randall, Jayapal vow oversight after Tacoma detention center sold for $453M

Rep. Emily Randall is fighting to conduct oversight after the GEO Group sold the Tacoma Detention Center to the U.S. government.

4 days ago

Mayor Wilson budget...

Luke Duecy

‘I am disappointed’: Seattle mayor warns city council budget changes could create future deficit

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson is warning that changes proposed by the city council to the city's next two-year budget could leave Seattle facing a deficit.

4 days ago

Gov. Ferguson wins appeal: WA AG’s Office cleared to probe Catholic Church sex abuse cover-up allegations