MYNORTHWEST POLITICS

Washington Supreme Court rejects Republican attempt to reject State’s assessment of initiatives

Oct 24, 2024, 11:11 AM

wa supreme court...

The mahogany, wing-shaped bench the Washington Supreme Court justices sit upon in the inner chambers of the Washington Supreme Court. (Photo courtesy of Washington State Courts)

(Photo courtesy of Washington State Courts)

In a decision with major implications for Washington’s upcoming election, the Washington Supreme Court rejected Rep. Jim Walsh’s, R-Aberdeen, bid Thursday that would have stopped the state from issuing financial impact statements related to three key initiatives.

Walsh challenged the fiscal assessments of three of those measures that are appearing on the November 2024 ballot:

  • I-2109, which would repeal the state’s capital gains tax.
  • I-2117, which would repeal the Washington Climate Commitment Act, a cap-and-trade program designed to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
  • I-2124, which would make participation in Washington’s long-term care insurance program, “WA Cares,” optional rather than mandatory.

More WA political news: Washington Supreme Court race becomes most expensive in state history

Walsh argued that the state’s Office of Financial Management (OFM) had made errors in calculating the financial effects of these initiatives.

He further claimed that Initiative 2109 would have no fiscal impact because the legislature had already effectively repealed the capital gains tax by enacting Initiative 2111, which prohibits income taxation.

The court, however, upheld a lower court decision and sided with state officials, ruling that the capital gains tax is an excise tax, not an income tax, and that its repeal would reduce state revenue, thus requiring a fiscal impact statement.

Walsh’s case sought an extraordinary legal order known as writs of prohibition and mandamus. These writs are rarely granted and are only available when no other legal remedies are present. The court ruled that the officials in question were following the law and did not exceed their authority, dismissing Walsh’s requests.

More from Matt Markovich: Show me the ‘Dark Money’ in Washington politics

Walsh’s legal challenge, which named Secretary of State Steve Hobbs, Attorney General Bob Ferguson and OFM Director David Schumacher as respondents, has now been dismissed.

The court had earlier ruled that the initiatives should show up on the November ballot with fiscal disclosures in place. Thursday’s ruling explains why the court ruled as it did.

Matt Markovich covers government and politics for MyNorthwest and KIRO Newsradio

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest Politics

port of tacoma...

Brooke Griffin, KIRO 7 News

Tacoma council adopts tough budget with 100 job cuts and new police hires

Tacoma Mayor Anders Ibsen said their main goal was to address a $40 million deficit, while also giving the community what it needs.

23 hours ago

WIAA transgender I-638 girls sports...

Frank Lenzi

WIAA prepares for Washington girls’ sports law as I-638 takes effect Dec. 3

A law restricting participation in girls' sports at schools to biological females takes effect Dec. 3, and the WIAA said it's working to ensure compliance.

23 hours ago

Tacoma detention center...

Julia Dallas

‘We’re coming after ICE’: Randall, Jayapal vow oversight after Tacoma detention center sold for $453M

Rep. Emily Randall is fighting to conduct oversight after the GEO Group sold the Tacoma Detention Center to the U.S. government.

24 hours ago

Mayor Wilson budget...

Luke Duecy

‘I am disappointed’: Seattle mayor warns city council budget changes could create future deficit

Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson is warning that changes proposed by the city council to the city's next two-year budget could leave Seattle facing a deficit.

1 day ago

wa B&O tax rob mckenna...

Manda Factor

Could WA replace its B&O tax? Rob McKenna weighs in

Rob McKenna discusses the challenges of replacing WA's B&O tax with a corporate income tax while maintaining revenue.

1 day ago

ferguson fraud prevention...

Charlie Harger

Harger: WA’s budget doubled in 10 years. Now Gov. Bob Ferguson wants 15% cuts

Governor Bob Ferguson aims for 15% cuts to Washington's budget after a decade of growth. Explore the impacts on local programs and services.

1 day ago

Washington Supreme Court rejects Republican attempt to reject State’s assessment of initiatives