SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Would you program a self-driving car to save your life or a pedestrian’s?

Jun 27, 2016, 4:05 PM | Updated: 4:12 pm

Self-driving cars are emerging as a popular technology, but as with any new technology, ethical dilemmas are becoming apparent. KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson decided to poll the studio and his listeners about how they would handle one big decision.

If a pedestrian is in the roadway and the self-driving car has to choose between killing the pedestrian or taking an action that would kill the passenger, what should the car do?

“Pedestrians have blindly stumbled into the road in front of your self-driving car,” Dori explained, after reading  an article on the subject. “There is not enough stopping distance to avoid hitting them — the only bailout for the self-driving car to avoid hitting the pedestrians is to crash into a concrete pillar in the middle of the road. But this will almost certainly kill the driver.”

Related: Analyst argues that self-driving cars will replace private car ownership in Seattle within 15 years

What should the self-driving car do — save the pedestrian or save the passenger?

Dori asked producer Nicole, board operator Sean, and anchor Maura. Nicole — believing she will survive anything from a car wreck to a plane crash — would want the car to spare the pedestrian. Maura agreed. But Sean and Dori feel differently. Sean pointed out that if pedestrians are in the roadway while the programmed car is driving, the car is likely doing what it should, and the pedestrians are doing something they should not.

“I’m going to program my car to kill … to protect myself and my family,” Sean said.

“If I’m buying a car, I want it to protect me,” Dori quickly agreed. “I want a loyal car.”

But he admits there are still dilemmas.

“If somebody stumbles in front of your vehicle — maybe they’re drunk, but maybe it’s a little kid chasing a ball that went into the street,” he said. “The car is not going to make that evaluation.”

Dori posed the questions to his listeners. As it turns out, Dori’s audience took his side. Out of six listeners, only one would save the pedestrian.

• Andy in Lacey would save the driver
• Anna in Olympia would save the driver
• Pete in Marysville would save the pedestrian
• John in Poulsbo would save the driver
• Rick in Spanaway would save the driver

What would Dori’s online audience do? Comment below.

Associated Press

Democrat Aaron Ford wins election for governor in Nevada

Democrat Aaron Ford won election Wednesday as governor of Nevada, defeating Republican incumbent Joe Lombardo. Ford, the attorney general, defeated the incumbent Lombardo in what was considered one of the country’s most competitive governor’s races. Ford ran with the backing of the Democratic congressional delegation, California Gov. Gavin Newsom and former Vice President Kamala Harris. […]

1 hour ago

Associated Press

Democrat Susie Lee wins reelection to U.S. House in Nevada’s 3rd Congressional District

Democrat Susie Lee won election Wednesday to the U.S. House of Representatives representing Nevada’s 3rd Congressional District, defeating Republican Marty O’Donnell. Lee won a fifth term representing Nevada’s most competitive district that includes part of metro Las Vegas and rural Clark County and which President Donald Trump won in 2024. First elected in 2018, Lee […]

2 hours ago

Associated Press

Republican Pete Ricketts wins reelection to U.S. Senate from Nebraska

Republican Pete Ricketts won election Wednesday to the U.S. Senate representing Nebraska, defeating independent candidate Dan Osborn. Ricketts will now serve his first full six-year term, following his 2023 appointment to replace Republican Sen. Ben Sasse and 2024 special election victory. Osborn, an industrial mechanic and military veteran, also ran in 2024 against the state’s […]

3 hours ago

Associated Press

Democrat Katie Hobbs wins reelection for governor in Arizona

Democrat Katie Hobbs won election Wednesday as governor of Arizona, defeating Republican Andy Biggs, Republican Gertritrude Gonzalez (write-in) and Republican Alice Novoa (write-in). Hobbs won despite being viewed as the most vulnerable Democratic governor in the country. She courted disaffected Republicans and independent voters to win a second term in the swing state. Hobbs also […]

3 hours ago

Associated Press

Republican Kurt Alme wins election to U.S. Senate from Montana

Republican Kurt Alme won election Wednesday to the U.S. Senate representing Montana, defeating independent Seth Bodnar and Democrat Alani Bankhead. Alme will replace Republican Sen. Steve Daines, who made a surprise announcement in March, just ahead of the state’s filing deadline, that he would not run for a third term. Both Daines and President Donald […]

3 hours ago

Associated Press

Republican Jim Pillen wins reelection for governor in Nebraska

Republican Jim Pillen won election Wednesday as governor of Nebraska, defeating Democrat Lynne Walz. Pillen, the incumbent governor who is also a hog farm owner, first assumed office in 2023. Walz is a former state senator. The Associated Press declared Pillen the winner at 2:53 a.m. EST.

3 hours ago

Would you program a self-driving car to save your life or a pedestrian’s?