SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

Would you program a self-driving car to save your life or a pedestrian’s?

Jun 27, 2016, 4:05 PM | Updated: 4:12 pm

Self-driving cars are emerging as a popular technology, but as with any new technology, ethical dilemmas are becoming apparent. KIRO Radio’s Dori Monson decided to poll the studio and his listeners about how they would handle one big decision.

If a pedestrian is in the roadway and the self-driving car has to choose between killing the pedestrian or taking an action that would kill the passenger, what should the car do?

“Pedestrians have blindly stumbled into the road in front of your self-driving car,” Dori explained, after reading  an article on the subject. “There is not enough stopping distance to avoid hitting them — the only bailout for the self-driving car to avoid hitting the pedestrians is to crash into a concrete pillar in the middle of the road. But this will almost certainly kill the driver.”

Related: Analyst argues that self-driving cars will replace private car ownership in Seattle within 15 years

What should the self-driving car do — save the pedestrian or save the passenger?

Dori asked producer Nicole, board operator Sean, and anchor Maura. Nicole — believing she will survive anything from a car wreck to a plane crash — would want the car to spare the pedestrian. Maura agreed. But Sean and Dori feel differently. Sean pointed out that if pedestrians are in the roadway while the programmed car is driving, the car is likely doing what it should, and the pedestrians are doing something they should not.

“I’m going to program my car to kill … to protect myself and my family,” Sean said.

“If I’m buying a car, I want it to protect me,” Dori quickly agreed. “I want a loyal car.”

But he admits there are still dilemmas.

“If somebody stumbles in front of your vehicle — maybe they’re drunk, but maybe it’s a little kid chasing a ball that went into the street,” he said. “The car is not going to make that evaluation.”

Dori posed the questions to his listeners. As it turns out, Dori’s audience took his side. Out of six listeners, only one would save the pedestrian.

• Andy in Lacey would save the driver
• Anna in Olympia would save the driver
• Pete in Marysville would save the pedestrian
• John in Poulsbo would save the driver
• Rick in Spanaway would save the driver

What would Dori’s online audience do? Comment below.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Michigan Democratic Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed speaks at a campaign rally, Saturday, Oct. 31, ...

Associated Press

Michigan Democrats’ unity push falters as Stevens is asked to skip event with El-Sayed

DETROIT (AP) — Michigan Democrats are heading to church in Detroit on Sunday in an attempt to present a united front behind Abdul El-Sayed in a race that could decide control of the U.S. Senate. But one prominent Democrat is expected to be missing from the pews. U.S. Rep. Haley Stevens, who lost in the […]

12 minutes ago

Oleh Tarabaka, head of the Nova Kakhovka military administration, left, and Vadym, a Ukrainian serg...

Associated Press

Civilians in Ukraine’s Kherson prepare for the return of war as localized ceasefire ends

KHERSON, Ukraine (AP) — Civilians in Ukraine’s southeastern Kherson region prepared Sunday for the end of a localized ceasefire that has marked the most significant truce between Kyiv and Moscow since Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine 4½ years ago. The White House said U.S. first lady Melania Trump helped to broker the limited truce, which […]

2 hours ago

This photo provided by Valerie Terranova shows a performance of the musical "In The Heights" at the...

Associated Press

Director calls Broadway revival of ‘In the Heights’ at NY City Center a ‘balm for these times’

NEW YORK (AP) — David Mendizábal vividly remembers sitting in the audience for the final performances of playwright Lin-Manuel Miranda’s “In the Heights.” Almost two decades later, Mendizábal is directing the musical that was once his “portal to the theater.” “It was the first time I’d ever heard or seen a world that looked and […]

2 hours ago

President Donald Trump speaks at a Halloween party at his Mar-a-Lago estate in Palm Beach, Fla., Sa...

Associated Press

Trump’s rallies in Iowa and Kansas come as Republicans fight to keep Senate and House control

WASHINGTON (AP) — President Donald Trump is closing out the final days of a turbulent midterm campaign with rallies in two states he has handily won in the past, underscoring the defensive posture his Republican Party is taking as the elections become a referendum on his White House second term. His first stop is scheduled […]

2 hours ago

FILE - President Donald Trump speaks and announces action to help farmers and ranchers, as a group ...

Associated Press

Trump administration promises US farmers $15 billion in weeks before the midterms

SIOUX FALLS, S.D. (AP) — President Donald Trump’s administration has made $15 billion worth of promises to agriculture producers in the last few weeks of the midterm elections, initiatives intended to help offset higher costs for diesel and fertilizer that farmers have endured largely due to his tariffs and the war in Iran. Whether that […]

3 hours ago

minimum wage (2)...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘They can’t afford to keep the ones that they have’: Jake and Spike clash over Seattle’s $22 minimum wage

KIRO host Jake Skorheim said the problem facing Seattle small businesses isn't finding workers.

3 hours ago

Would you program a self-driving car to save your life or a pedestrian’s?