DAVE ROSS

Is believing in truth more important than believing in God?

Mar 1, 2017, 11:46 AM

Professor Sean Carroll says belief in God isn't what keeps society from resorting to savagery.(Mark...

Professor Sean Carroll says belief in God isn't what keeps society from resorting to savagery.(Mark Heybo, Flickr)

(Mark Heybo, Flickr)

Professor Sean Carroll is a theoretical physicist at CalTech, and like most of us believes in truth.

“Most people don’t want to be lied to,” he says.

So he wrote a book called “The Big Picture: On the Origins of Life, Meaning, and the Universe Itself.”  And in it, he has a message for people who believe in God.

“Well, I think that their belief in God, in particular, is not the best way to account for the universe we see,” Professor Carroll says.

Related: Should a recent discovery change the way you read the Bible?

Because there is now a huge body of research showing that the universe – and life – can be explained objectively as the movement of molecules. It’s called Naturalism.

“Naturalism is the idea that the physical world, the world that we see, the natural world, is all that there is,” he says.

But if there’s no God to watch and judge people – wouldn’t we all just revert to savagery?

“I don’t think that most people want to be good people only because God tells them to do that,” he says. “I think most people actually just want to be good.”

And you might say, what about the movie “It’s a Wonderful Life,” where Jimmy Stewart plays George Bailey, the failed banker who decides to jump off a bridge but is saved by his guardian angel?

Well, Dr. Carroll says, actually, it’s George Bailey who saves himself.

“The thing that saves him is the realization that he had a positive impact on all the other real people there in Bedford Falls,” Carroll says. “If you believe my way of looking at the world, that is what is real, and that is what mattered.”

So feel free to believe in God, but Dr. Carroll just wants you to know that’s it’s not supported by the laws of physics.  So don’t go trying to pray rockets into orbit.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

Dave Ross

Image: From left, Chris Sullivan, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien stand together in the KIRO Newsradi...

MyNorthwest Staff

Dave and Colleen’s final ‘SMN:’ KIRO colleagues, politicians say their goodbyes

"Seattle's Morning News" on KIRO Newsradio will soon have a new sound. On Thursday, Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien will host their last show together after a decade of co-hosting.

2 years ago

Classical literature on bookshelves. (Photo by Richard Baker / In Pictures via Getty Images)...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross as you’ve never heard him before: ‘I like fat books and I can’t deny’

"This song, inspired by one of my first interviews when I started my talk show, which was Sir Mix-A-Lot," Dave Ross said.

2 years ago

national debt...

Dave Ross

‘Don’t cut a cent:’ Dave Ross on why the national debt never gets under control

The national debt now exceeds $36 trillion, and every president says it has to be under control. And yet, it never is.

2 years ago

voters hormone...

Dave Ross

Ross: Voters weren’t just voting for change, they were voting for a hormone

The more I read the post-election analysis, the more I’m convinced voters weren’t just voting for a change – they were voting for a hormone.

2 years ago

ross o'brien - Seattle's Morning News...

Frank Sumrall

Dave Ross, Colleen O’Brien departing after co-hosting ‘Seattle’s Morning News’ for a decade

Dave Ross and Colleen O'Brien, the co-hosts of "Seattle's Morning News" on KIRO Newsradio are both leaving the show.

2 years ago

election day...

Dave Ross

Dave Ross: Election Day and Decision Day are two separate things

Tomorrow is Election Day – that’s what the calendar says. But there are two problems with the term "Election Day."

2 years ago

Is believing in truth more important than believing in God?