KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

Ross: Federal judge rules you have the right to be misinformed

Jul 6, 2023, 11:44 AM

This week, a Louisiana federal judge granted a preliminary injunction in favor of the attorneys general of Missouri and Louisiana in the case of Missouri v. Biden, which is about whether officials of the federal government had any business contacting social media platforms like Twitter and urging them to delete what was considered misinformation.

Several government agencies have done this, including the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the surgeon general asking the websites to remove posts pushing bogus COVID-19 cures or alleging that the vaccine was more dangerous than the virus. And, of course, the FBI discouraged posts about what was on Hunter Biden’s laptop.

The injunction has some people really upset that a judge would prohibit what amounts to fact-checking. But I will say, in my own experience, getting a complaint from a government official feels very different than getting a complaint from a listener. I can see how a website operator might feel intimidated.

More on the case: Injunction blocks Biden administration from working with social media firms about ‘protected speech’

At the same time, websites, unlike broadcast stations, have zero legal responsibility to fact check what they publish, even if the information ends up harming their audience.

And now, under this injunction, the government can’t even warn them about the harm they might do.

Under the order, officials of the CDC, the FBI and even the State Department are prohibited from emailing, calling, sending letters, texting, or engaging in any communication of any kind for the purpose of changing content.

More from Dave Ross: Maybe graffiti would be nicer if it was more cheerful

The judge also said if the government wants a post removed or altered, that post would have to involve outright crimes or threats to national security. But other than that, anything goes.

So that’s the new rule for now. Not only are websites legally protected from being sued over the consequences of misinformation, the government can’t even warn them about the harm they might do.

This is the first amendment protecting the right to be misinformed.

I know that for some people, this is outrageous. But for those who feel censored, the pressure from the government was just as outrageous. So this is another one of those issues which will have to be resolved outside the courtroom.

More from Dave Ross: Unequal treatment in Hunter Biden gun charges is outrageous

It will have to be resolved by the laws of nature, but you’re not subject to court injunctions or sentencing guidelines. And under the laws of nature, following bad advice during a pandemic can get you sentenced to a long hospital stay or worse. But that’s how freedom works, it protects your right to be misinformed and to take the consequences. That’s how we evolve.

The law of natural selection can be cruel, but it’s very effective. In any case, it can’t be enjoined, even by a federal judge.

Listen to Seattle’s Morning News with Dave Ross and Colleen O’Brien weekday mornings from 5-9 a.m. on KIRO Newsradio, 97.3 FM. Subscribe to the podcast here.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

Dave's Commentary

Dave Ross on KIRO Newsradio 97.3 FM
  • listen to dave rossTune in to KIRO Newsradio weekdays at 5am for Dave Ross on Seattle's Morning News.

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

Seattle Cameras CCTV AI Mayor Katie Wilson...

John Curley Show

‘That’s always the big problem’: Curley questions data privacy as Mayor Wilson expands Seattle surveillance cameras

KIRO Newsradio host John Curley questioned whether Seattle’s planned safeguards for police surveillance cameras can keep pace with technology.

8 hours ago

Microsoft president...

John Curley Show

‘They take the jobs with them’: Curley doubts Olympia will heed Microsoft’s call for budget stability

KIRO host John Curley is skeptical that state leaders will follow Microsoft President Brad Smith’s call for budget stability and affordability.

9 hours ago

James Bond robert pattinson...

Jake Skorheim

Jake: I don’t like the new James Bond pick, but my wife sure does

I told my wife that the new James Bond is the guy who played Edward Cullen in "Twilight." Suddenly, she wants to see the Bond movies. For the first time. Ever.

10 hours ago

Seattle homeless...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘What we’re doing isn’t working’: Ursula urges Seattle to study San Francisco’s approach to homelessness, drug treatment

Ursula Reutin calls for Seattle to adopt San Francisco's effective strategies for addressing homelessness and public drug use.

14 hours ago

Husky Stadium UW naming rights athletics salaries Ursula nuts...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘I think that’s nuts’: Ursula questions coach salaries as UW sells Husky Stadium naming rights

The University of Washington's, UW, stadium in Seattle, naming deal raises questions, with Ursula critiquing the UW athletic department and coaches salaries.

15 hours ago

Harger Seattle Jackson 12th addiction son...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Every Sunday, a mom went to 12th and Jackson to see if her son was still alive. Saturday, I met her

Every Sunday at 1 p.m., a mother went to the corner of 12th and Jackson in Seattle and waited. Her son lived on the streets and refused help. So every week, she hoped he’d be there. She hoped he’d still be alive.

15 hours ago

Ross: Federal judge rules you have the right to be misinformed