KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

Harger: Families asked a reporter to cover their school closure meeting. Seattle Public Schools tried to throw her out

Nov 19, 2026, 7:23 AM

seattle publics schools reporter superintendent...

Seattle Public Schools logo. (Photo courtesy of KIRO 7 News).

(Photo courtesy of KIRO 7 News)

Ben Shuldiner is deciding the future of Seattle Public Schools. He’s deciding which ones close, how fast, and what happens to buildings and budgets paid for with your tax money.

Last night, the Seattle School Board gave the superintendent even more control over that process and dropped the requirement to publicly explain why a school needs to close.

Two days earlier, in a public school, in front of about 80 parents, he said a reporter’s presence made the room “unsafe.”

The reporter was Tracy Record. She’s been a journalist since she was 17, and she edits the West Seattle Blog. On Monday night, she sat on the side of the room at Highland Park Elementary, where Shuldiner met with families about a plan to close Sanislo Elementary and merge it into Highland Park. According to her account, a district official told her the meeting wasn’t open to the media and that she needed to leave.

She politely refused.

Good. Don’t you dare move.

Then Shuldiner warned the room a reporter was there. Record didn’t hide. She raised her hand high so every parent could see exactly who she was. This was no undercover investigation. She was a journalist, sitting in plain sight, telling everyone why she was there.

Shuldiner told the room she’d been asked to leave. According to record, several parents objected out loud and stood up for her.

Then the superintendent said her presence made the meeting “unsafe” for families.
Absolutely not.

Shuldiner was just given sweeping new powers to close schools. Reporters in rooms like that one are now more important than ever.

Seattle Public Schools says a reporter made the Sanislo meeting “unsafe”

This meeting was about closing a public school. It happened in a public building, was run by a public official, and involved public land and taxpayer money. Sure, the invitation went to families. But everyone who pays for Seattle schools has a stake in the decision, and the media has a duty to cover it.

The families themselves forwarded the district’s messages to the West Seattle Blog and asked Record to cover the meeting. She told them she planned to.

Parents at that meeting talked about real hardship. One mom said a lot of Sanislo families are very poor. She doesn’t drive, and getting to Highland Park would take her half an hour. Some parents might not want words like that in print, and that’s a fair worry.

But Record says nobody was asked for personal or sensitive information, and nobody offered any. A good reporter can keep a worried parent’s name out of a story.

Shutting a reporter out of that room protects the officials deciding which schools close. Without a reporter there, nobody outside the room learns what families asked or how the district answered.

Seattle School Board gives Ben Shuldiner more control over school closures

Last night, the board voted unanimously to rewrite its school-closure policy. KOMO News reports the changes took effect immediately and could apply to the mergers on the table right now.

The board dropped two waiting periods meant for public review: 30 days after the superintendent’s preliminary closure recommendation, and 14 more after his final one. The superintendent also no longer has to publicly explain why a closure is necessary.

This board move didn’t surprise the superintendent. Directors reviewed the changes at a policy meeting back on Oct. 28. So on Monday night, when his district tried to remove a reporter from the room, Shuldiner knew the board was two days away from giving him more say over how fast schools close, with less obligation to explain why.

That was the week to welcome reporters into the room.

Board Director Joe Mizrahi says the change doesn’t cut a single public hearing or chance to comment. The hearings still happen, just sooner, and the district will still hold them at or near each affected school. Shuldiner says the board can still stop a closure with a majority vote. “The board could just say, ‘No, Ben,’ and then I can’t do it.”

Maybe so. But there’s less time to review, and the superintendent doesn’t have to explain himself in public. That puts more weight on family meetings like the one at Highland Park. For many parents, those rooms may be the only place they hear the district’s reasons. Somebody should be there writing it down.

Ben Shuldiner earned credit for candor on school mergers

I’ve praised Shuldiner before. When he announced the mergers, he admitted in writing that some of his own district’s enrollment decline was self-inflicted. Seattle hasn’t heard that kind of straight talk from a superintendent in a long time.

He was straight with families Monday, too. He told them he has to “play the hand that’s dealt” to him. He promised nobody at either school would lose their job and that the Sanislo building won’t be sold while he’s in charge. He promised to stay after the meeting ran long for one-on-one conversations.

But Shuldiner backed up the call to remove Record in front of the whole room, two days before the board handed him more power. I’ve reached out to Seattle Public Schools for its side of the story and will update this column if the district responds.

If it went down the way Record describes, that’s too far.

Washington’s Open Public Meetings Act and the business of the public

It was a public meeting in every way that counts. It was held in a public school, run by a public official, and part of the official process that decides whether neighborhood schools close. Parents lined up at a microphone and spoke in front of 80 people. And every dollar on the table, from Sanislo’s building to the staff who’d move to Highland Park, is your tax money.

Washington’s open meetings law opens with a line every public official should know by heart: “The people do not yield their sovereignty to the agencies which serve them.”

The district is weighing 21 schools for mergers. Families will lose neighborhood schools they love, and buildings worth millions will sit empty or get new uses. People who manage that much of our money should expect to be watched and reported on.

How Seattle Public Schools can fix this before meeting 26

Shuldiner called Monday’s session “meeting number 25 out of 47.” That leaves plenty of time to get this right.

He can tell his staff that reporters are welcome at every remaining family meeting. Starting now builds trust with families who already feel like Sanislo has been shortchanged.

West Seattle Blog’s Tracy Record stood her ground and reported it straight

Record could have packed up and left. A district official told her to go, and then the superintendent called her out in front of 80 parents. Plenty of people would have walked out. She stayed in her seat.

Then she did the job, and she did it fairly. Her story lays out Shuldiner’s case for the merger in his own words: the aging buildings, the grades with only one class, and his promise that nobody loses their job. She quoted the Sanislo mom who doesn’t drive and would face a half-hour ride to Highland Park.

She quoted Highland Park parents worried about losing their principal. And she quoted the dad who stood up and backed the merger. She even noted that Shuldiner promised to stay as long as families needed for one-on-one conversations.

That’s what a scrappy neighborhood reporter looks like. She showed up, she didn’t get pushed around, and she gave the people who tried to remove her a fair shake.

Shuldiner wants families to trust him with their schools. He can start by trusting them with a reporter in the room.

Charlie Harger is the host of “Seattle’s Morning News” on KIRO Newsradio. You can read more of his stories and commentaries here. Follow Charlie on X and email him here.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

Jimothy Seattle City Council Rob Saka...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It’s still a very bad idea’: Jake and Spike mock illuminated Jimothy statue with Rob Saka impression

A discussion about an illuminated Jimothy raccoon statue turned into a mock Seattle City Council meeting where Spike O’Neill impersonated Councilmember Rob Saka.

1 hour ago

seattle publics schools reporter superintendent...

Charlie Harger

Harger: Families asked a reporter to cover their school closure meeting. Seattle Public Schools tried to throw her out

The Seattle School Board gave the superintendent, Ben Shuldiner, even more control over that process and dropped the requirement that he publicly explain why a school needs to close.

1 hour ago

toxic relationship...

Ursula Reutin

Ask Ursula: Should I stay in a toxic relationship because dating in Seattle in my 50s is hard?

Should you stay in a toxic relationship because you’re afraid to be alone? Ursula weighs in.

4 hours ago

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella...

Jake Skorheim and Spike O'Neill Show

‘It feels bad actory to me’: Jake doubts the tech outages were a coincidence as Microsoft CEO promises resilience

Microsoft CEO Satya Nadella said last week’s global outage showed how much the world depends on his company’s services.

15 hours ago

In this photo illustration, a case for the upcoming console game "Grand Theft Auto 6", also known a...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘What good is there in this?’: Ursula questions Grand Theft Auto’s violence as KIRO hosts debate taking time off to play

KIRO Newsradio's Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin discuss the impact of Grand Theft Auto's violence and its implications for players ahead of the new release.

19 hours ago

wa income tax ferguson...

John Curley Show

‘That money’s not going to be there’: Curley warns residents could leave WA as Ferguson counts on income tax revenue

John Curley criticized state spending and questioned Gov. Ferguson’s confidence in future tax revenue as Washington faces a projected $4 billion shortfall.

23 hours ago

Harger: Families asked a reporter to cover their school closure meeting. Seattle Public Schools tried to throw her out