KIRO NEWSRADIO OPINION

Jake and Spike disagree over WA AG Nick Brown joining multistate lawsuit challenging Trump’s fuel economy rollback

Oct 6, 2026, 8:51 AM

Washington Attorney General Nick Brown joined a multistate lawsuit Friday challenging a new federal rule that sharply lowers fuel economy standards for new cars and light trucks.

The rule, announced last Monday by Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, sets a fleetwide target of 34.9 miles per gallon for model year 2031, down from the 50.4 projected under Biden-era rules.

“It’s hard not for the Trump administration to be painted as in the pocket of Big Oil,” KIRO host Spike O’Neill said. “This is being easily portrayed as a gift to the big oil donors of his political campaigns, his organizations, his movement, if you will, and automakers who are also big supporters of this administration.”

The coalition, led by California Attorney General Rob Bonta, argued in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit that the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) broke federal law by failing to set the standards at the “maximum feasible” level. It said the agency changed its modeling to exclude electric vehicles from the baseline.

The Department of Transportation (DOT), which calls the rule its “Freedom Means Affordable Cars” initiative, said it will cut the average price of a new vehicle by $1,300. NHTSA’s own analysis estimates drivers will burn an additional 122 billion gallons of gasoline through 2050, a 4.6% increase over the baseline.

Auto Innovators, the trade group for major automakers, called the rule “an appropriate course correction.”

“It’s in the best interest of a car manufacturer, I believe, to want to produce a car that’s both a good value and is as fuel efficient to run for the customer without being mandated at some level that requires them to be so expensive that the customer can no longer afford that vehicle,” KIRO host Jake Skorheim said. “The 50.4 miles per gallon seems to me to be excessively high, and you got to do it very quickly.”

Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards set the average mileage automakers must reach across the new vehicles they sell, under a law Congress passed in 1975. NHTSA noted that real-world fuel economy typically runs 20% to 30% below the compliance figure. The new rule also ends the program that lets automakers trade compliance credits starting in model year 2028.

Brown’s office said the rollback lets manufacturers ease up on fuel-saving improvements and leaves drivers paying more at the pump. The coalition also argues NHTSA’s analysis ignores nearly $220 billion in fuel savings drivers would have gotten under the previous standards.

“There’s a point where government oversight is in the best interest of the population with regard to pollution,” Spike said. “You look back at the ’70s and what cars did to the environment then, with lead, gasoline, and all the low mileage standards. There’s a point where the free market shouldn’t be allowed to decide. Profit shouldn’t be the only motivating factor or the only driving factor of an industry with regard to the public good.”

The standards at issue are set by the federal government, and Washington’s role in the case is as a plaintiff.

“I think it’s unfair for the state of Washington to arbitrarily set numbers that they can’t even back up or prove are even happening, or that they can change in any meaningful way, while expecting you to pay more for the car that you purchase and the gas that you purchase,” Jake said. “That seems unfair to me.”

Watch the full discussion in the video above.

Listen to “The Jake and Spike Show” weekdays from noon to 3 p.m. on KIRO Newsradio 97.3

KIRO Newsradio Opinion

wa girls sports i-638...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘This is going to be a mess’: Gee raises concerns about girls missing competitions under WA’s new verification rules

New verification rules in Washington raise alarms about girls missing sports competitions. Insights on I-638 and its impact.

7 hours ago

seattle katie wilson budget...

John Curley Show

‘Three cheers for Katie Wilson’: Curley praises Seattle mayor’s budget restraint, decision to expand police cameras

John Curley celebrated Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson's budget plan, emphasizing fiscal restraint while expanding police camera initiatives for community safety.

10 hours ago

KIRO Newsradio app idea...

Charlie Harger

Harger: My trillion-dollar idea for the KIRO Newsradio app

Explore Charlie Harger's innovative vision for the KIRO Newsradio app and how it could reshape your listening and gaming experience.

13 hours ago

kratom edmonds death...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘Withdrawal from kratom is horrific’: KIRO producer describes his struggle as Edmonds family pushes for sales ban

KIRO producer Andrew Lanier shares his withdrawal struggle as an Edmonds family seeks to ban kratom following their son's death.

13 hours ago

seattle superintendent ipad school...

Gee Scott and Ursula Reutin Show

‘You are here to be the fall guy’: Gee and Ursula criticize Seattle School Board for handing school closure power to superintendent

The Seattle School Board has given Superintendent Ben Shuldiner the power to close or merge schools without a final board vote.

1 day ago

health care...

John Curley Show

‘It’s not their money’: Curley asks who will be held accountable for WA health care error that could cost $654 million

KIRO host John Curley is asking whether anyone will lose their job after a reporting error by the Washington State Health Care Authority.

1 day ago

Jake and Spike disagree over WA AG Nick Brown joining multistate lawsuit challenging Trump’s fuel economy rollback