MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Puyallup vandals who damaged nearly 90 cars charged

Nov 22, 2013, 4:26 PM | Updated: 4:32 pm

A vandal is caught on camera damaging a pickup truck during a week-long spree in Puyallup, Nov. 8, ...

A vandal is caught on camera damaging a pickup truck during a week-long spree in Puyallup, Nov. 8, 2013. (Puyallup Police image)

(Puyallup Police image)

The three vandals who damaged nearly 90 cars in a week-long spree in Puyallup now face multiple charges, Pierce County Prosecutor Mark Lindquist said Friday.

Tyler Graham, 24, Nicole Simons, 22, and James Reynolds, 19, are charged with Malicious Mischief in the Second and Third Degree.

“This was senseless vandalism,” Lindquist. “Destroying property like this demonstrates the defendants’ lack of respect for their own community.”

The three are accused of driving around Puyallup late at night, starting on Nov. 2, swinging an aluminum baseball bat at cars parked on the street.

Graham allegedly drove while Reynolds broke windows and side mirrors as he hung out of the car. Simons sat in the front passenger seat and was the lookout, Lindquist said.

A video surveillance camera caught Simons swinging a bat at the window of a pickup truck parked in the Puyallup Eagles lot on Nov. 8, leading to the arrests.

According to Lindquist, Graham told detectives that he didn’t feel bad about damaging the vehicles because most of them “were old.” Reynolds’ only explanation was “it’s a good stress reliever.”

Investigators have documented damage to 86 separate vehicles, but believe more victims may still come forward.

All three were held Friday on $50,000 bail.

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest News

mckinney duresky Congressional District 4...

Frank Sumrall

Trump-endorsed McKinney, Democrat Duresky advance in WA-4 primary to replace Newhouse

Republican Amanda McKinney and Democrat John Duresky are set to advance to the November general election for the recently vacated Washington Congressional District 4 seat.

4 hours ago

adam smith doug basler sawant...

Frank Sumrall

Adam Smith, Doug Basler to face off for sixth time in WA-9 race, Sawant comes up short in primary

Democrat incumbent Adam Smith and Republican challenger Doug Basler will advance to the November election to represent Washington's 9th Congressional District.

4 hours ago

Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez john braun primary...

Frank Sumrall

Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez edges John Braun by 263 votes in WA-3 primary

Democrat incumbent Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez and Republican challenger John Braun will face off for Washington's District 3 seat in the U.S. House of Representatives following results from the 2026 primary election.

6 hours ago

Sheriff (KSO) King County...

James Lynch

‘We are building safer communities’: King County receives $15M grant to strengthen crisis response, prevent gun violence

King County Executive Girmay Zahilay announced Tuesday that King County received a $15 million grant.

9 hours ago

crash near everett mall...

MyNorthwest Staff

I-5 south down to 1 lane after deadly crash near Everett Mall

I-5 south is down to one lane after a deadly crash near the Everett Mall.

9 hours ago

drug ring pnw leader...

Jason Sutich

‘He didn’t stop’: 25-year-old drug ring leader gets 10+ years despite repeated seizures across PNW

A leader of a drug trafficking ring was sentenced to 130 months in prison after he was persistent in bringing large amounts of drugs to Washington.

10 hours ago

Puyallup vandals who damaged nearly 90 cars charged