MYNORTHWEST NEWS

Valley Medical Center, lab ordered to pay $50 million for failed test

Dec 10, 2013, 5:44 PM | Updated: 5:47 pm

A King County jury has ordered Valley Medical Center and Laboratory Corporation of America to pay $50 million dollars for failing to accurately identify a severe genetic abnormality during a Burien woman’s preganancy.

Rhea Wuth’s obstetrician referred her to the Renton Hospital in 2007 to test for genetic disorders in her unborn child because her husband Brock and his family were known to carry a rare, extremely disabling disorder.

Attorney Todd Gardner says the couple was told their baby would be healthy, but later would discover the correct test was never done.

Gardner says as a result, now 5-year-old Ollie was born with serious cognitive and physical defects that will require life-long medical care.

“It was a combination of mistakes at Valley Medical Center where their Maternal Fetal Medicine Center was understaffed to the point that the people who should have been there making the decisions about the tests and getting the right information to the lab were not there,” Gardner says.

Gardner accuses the hospital of putting profits before patients because it cut genetic counseling from three days a week to just one, and failing to replace the full time MFM manager.

Valley Medical Center apologized but defended its actions in a statement to KING 5:

“We are very sorry for the tragedy the Wuth family has suffered. We continue to believe…staff members acted appropriately.”

Please follow our Community Guidelines

MyNorthwest News

adam smith doug basler sawant...

Frank Sumrall

Adam Smith, Doug Basler to face off for sixth time in WA-9 race, Sawant comes up short in primary

Democrat incumbent Adam Smith and Republican challenger Doug Basler will advance to the November election to represent Washington's 9th Congressional District.

29 minutes ago

Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez john braun primary...

Frank Sumrall

Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez edges John Braun by 263 votes in WA-3 primary

Democrat incumbent Marie Gluesenkamp Pérez and Republican challenger John Braun will face off for Washington's District 3 seat in the U.S. House of Representatives following results from the 2026 primary election.

2 hours ago

Sheriff (KSO) King County...

James Lynch

‘We are building safer communities’: King County receives $15M grant to strengthen crisis response, prevent gun violence

King County Executive Girmay Zahilay announced Tuesday that King County received a $15 million grant.

5 hours ago

crash near everett mall...

MyNorthwest Staff

I-5 south down to 1 lane after deadly crash near Everett Mall

I-5 south is down to one lane after a deadly crash near the Everett Mall.

5 hours ago

drug ring pnw leader...

Jason Sutich

‘He didn’t stop’: 25-year-old drug ring leader gets 10+ years despite repeated seizures across PNW

A leader of a drug trafficking ring was sentenced to 130 months in prison after he was persistent in bringing large amounts of drugs to Washington.

7 hours ago

Bothell Fred Meyer fire...

MyNorthwest Staff

Bothell Fred Meyer evacuated for fire, store closed while crews ventilate building

The Fred Meyer in Bothell was evacuated Tuesday afternoon due to a fire inside the store.

8 hours ago

Valley Medical Center, lab ordered to pay $50 million for failed test