Totaled car? New WA law stops insurers from lowballing payout or repairs

If you’ve ever had your car banged up and felt like your insurance company lowballed the repair estimate or the total value of your car, the Washington State Senate just did something you’re going to want to hear about.

In a 29-20 vote Tuesday, the Senate gave the green light to Engrossed Senate Bill 5721, which is all about putting more power back in the hands of drivers when they disagree with their insurer over the value of damage to their car.

The House passed the bill with overwhelming support (96-1), and the Senate has now agreed to the House’s amendments, meaning the bill is heading to the governor’s desk.

What’s this bill really about?

At its core, ESB 5721 guarantees your right to an independent appraisal if you think your insurance company is lowballing you on how much your damaged car is worth—and it applies to first-party claims, meaning your insurance covering your vehicle, not someone else’s.

Starting January 1, 2026, every auto policy in the state would have to include a provision that allows either you or your insurer to request an appraisal if you can’t agree on the amount of damage or what your car is worth after a wreck.

Basically, it creates a formal “let’s get a second opinion” system that both sides have to follow.

How does the process work?

Let’s say your insurance company tells you your crumpled front end is worth $2,000 in damage, and you say, “No way, it’s more like $6,000.” With this new law:

• You or your insurer can demand an appraisal.
• Both sides pick a competent and neutral appraiser.
• If the two appraisers can’t agree, they bring in a third-party umpire.
• That umpire is chosen by both sides or, if necessary, appointed by the Office of the Insurance Commissioner (OIC).
• The result of the appraisal is binding, so there’s no more back-and-forth or drawn-out legal drama.

Under the original version of the bill, if the appraisal showed your damage was at least $500 more than what your insurance company first offered, the insurer would’ve had to pay for your appraisal costs.

But the House removed that aspect. So now, both sides cover their own costs—but the process still beats hiring a lawyer and spending months in court.

Why this matters

People are fed up with AI-generated damage estimates based on a couple of photos. Multiple people testified during the bill’s public hearings that their initial estimates were wildly low, sometimes 50% to 75% less than what actual repairs cost.

“This is about fairness,” said Senator Derek Stanford (D-Bothell), the bill’s lead sponsor.

The Office of the Insurance Commissioner has reported a spike in complaints—88% of them tied to disagreements over car damage value and how claims are handled.

Not everyone’s cheering

Insurance companies are not exactly thrilled.

The Northwest Insurance Council and the American Property Casualty Insurance Association opposed the bill, arguing that it’ll raise costs, slow down claims, and basically open the floodgates to endless appraisals—especially now that even a $500 gap can send things to arbitration.

Now that the Senate’s signed off on the final version, the bill is just one signature away from becoming law. If Washington Governor Bob Ferguson signs it, this new rule kicks in for policies issued or renewed on or after January 1, 2026.

Matt Markovich is the KIRO Newsradio political analyst. Follow him on X. Read more of his stories here.

Follow @https://twitter.com/mattmarkovich