SEATTLE NEWS ARCHIVES & FEATURES

We need to take a long, hard look at our country’s immigration policy

Nov 27, 2018, 2:51 PM

Migrants tear gassed at the U.S. Mexico border...

Migrants run from tear gas launched by U.S. agents, amid photojournalists covering the Mexico-U.S. border, after a group of migrants got past Mexican police at the Chaparral crossing in Tijuana, Mexico on Sunday. (AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd)

(AP Photo/Rodrigo Abd)

Sometimes an interesting thing happens when I publish my daily “What Are We Talking About Here.” It somehow begins to circulate online in circles that enjoy pouncing on my Twitter and Facebook feeds and blowing up the comments section, usually in a negative way.

Such was the case when I wrote about U.S. agents using tear gas against men, women, and children at the U.S. and Mexico border on Sunday.

RELATED: Tear gassing migrants isn’t the image I want for America

Usually it follows this pattern:

“Hey Ron, but what about this and what about that?”

Then, “those people are breaking the law, or they are a bunch of criminals, or what they’re doing is illegal. Therefore, they deserve everything that is happening to them.”

Next, “Ron — you’re stupid.”

Finally, “Ron — you’re stupid and you’re an idiot.”

Typically, I don’t respond, but I thought I’d make an exception this time, because I believe it’s at the very heart of why things are deteriorating so much right now.

Let’s start with the premise that immigration policy in the U.S. is currently broken and dysfunctional. I would agree with that wholeheartedly. I would also agree that the system has been abused in the past and needs to be overhauled. So far, I hope that most of us are on the same page.

So what we’re really talking about is methodology. How, when, and why should we allow people to enter the United States? This, I think is a much more interesting question.

Since at least WWII, the U.S. has had an official, legal process that evaluates whether a foreign person should be allowed to enter and live in the country. The real question is, do harsh deterrents work as an immigration policy?

This is where you need a clear policy that applies across the board. If only we had such a thing.

Oh wait, we do. It’s called the law. I get it if you disagree with the law, but there is a law on the books.

A few things are pretty clear.

As University of California lawyer and legal scholar Teri Kanefield pointed on Twitter, it’s not legal for the United States to launch a chemical agent into a bordering country, and there is a clearly defined asylum process already on the books.

When an asylum seeker reaches the border of the United States, even without any documents, they legally have several options: They can present themselves for admission at a port of entry, and claim asylum or “fear of persecution,” or they can enter illegally and present themselves to an official as quickly as possible and claim asylum or “fear of persecution.”

They then are legally entitled to a hearing to determine if they are eligible for asylum status. Therefore, when migrants “rush” to the border (if their intent is to seek asylum) they are within their rights.

So to all the people who are berating me online that these people should just follow the law, I would offer that two wrongs don’t make a right. If we expect immigrants to abide by the law, shouldn’t we expect the same of ourselves?

FILE - This combination of images shows Blake Lively at the London screening of the film "It 'Ends ...

Associated Press

Judge grants Blake Lively $400,000 of $8M in legal fees she sought in film fight with Justin Baldoni

NEW YORK (AP) — Blake Lively will get just over $400,000 of the $8 million she sought in legal costs from actor and director Justin Baldoni after they settled their fight over the production of their 2024 film “It Ends With Us,” a federal judge ruled Wednesday. Judge Lewis J. Liman explained in a written […]

5 minutes ago

Mount Rainier inn unsafe pierce county...

Jason Sutich

Pierce County deems Mount Rainier inn unsafe, orders closure after it rented rooms despite violations

All buildings at the Gateway Inn in Pierce County were deemed unsafe on Aug. 5, and everyone on the property has been ordered to leave immediately.

37 minutes ago

pierce county sheriff elect...

Frank Sumrall

Pierce County officials sue to block charter amendment that would remove elected sheriff

Multiple Pierce County officials are suing the county to challenge a proposal that would change the position of sheriff from elected to appointed.

40 minutes ago

People stand at the doors of the Maryland State House on Tuesday, Aug. 4, 2026, in Annapolis, Md. (...

Associated Press

Maryland court rules Democratic-backed redistricting amendment cannot go on November ballot

A Maryland court has ruled against a proposed constitutional amendment that could have paved the way for Democrats to redraw the state’s congressional districts ahead of the 2028 elections. The ruling Wednesday by a judge in the state’s capital city marks another setback in Democrats’ national attempts to counter a Republican redistricting movement pushed by […]

58 minutes ago

A Gideon Bible sits on a table in Phoenix, Sunday Aug. 23, 2026. (AP Photo/Dario Lopez-Mills)Credit...

Associated Press

For over 100 years, travelers have checked into US motel rooms and found the Gideon Bible

SALISBURY, Md. (AP) — “Rocky Raccoon checked into his room, only to find Gideon’s Bible.” Paul McCartney explained those famous lines in the song by The Beatles, saying these Bibles “were in every hotel in America.” He’d never seen something like that in England. For more than a century, countless have found it in the […]

1 hour ago

FILE - A sign for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration is displayed outside their offices in Silve...

Associated Press

FDA approves landmark pancreatic cancer drug that’s shown to improve survival

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Food and Drug Administration on Wednesday approved a groundbreaking new drug for the most common form of pancreatic cancer, offering U.S. patients a more effective treatment against one of the deadliest types of cancer. FDA officials gave expedited approval to the first-of-a-kind pill, called daraxonrasib, that blocks a mutated protein that […]

2 hours ago

We need to take a long, hard look at our country’s immigration policy