Ask Ursula: Should I stay in a toxic relationship because dating in Seattle in my 50s is hard?
Nov 19, 2026, 5:00 AM
I’m Ursula Reutin, one of the co-hosts of “The Gee and Ursula Show” on KIRO Newsradio.
Welcome to today’s edition of Ask Ursula, my advice column on MyNorthwest.
Dear Ursula,
I’ve been dating a guy for about a year. I’ve known him for a long time. We’re both in our 50s, and we worked together for many years. But during that time, we were both married. In fact, he and his wife were still married when we started hooking up. Now they’re divorced.
There are a few parts of our relationship that are good. We both like to travel, and we go on cool trips. But he and I argue all the time, and our fights get ugly. Really ugly. They’ve never been physical, but we’re both verbally and emotionally abusive toward each other. Him more so than me. He’s called me terrible names and has been very hurtful, usually when he’s had a lot to drink.
It gets so bad that I keep threatening to break up and kick him out of my house. But then he apologizes and behaves for a while. Then the pattern repeats. Now, I’ve told him that he has run out of chances. The next time he disrespects me, he’s out of my life for good.
I know this is unhealthy, and I know I put up with a lot of this BS because I was raised in an abusive home with a mom who didn’t know how to show love. I was also in a physically abusive marriage for over a decade. But I have to be honest. I’m scared to be alone. And dating in the Seattle area sucks, especially when you’re in your 50s. There aren’t a lot of choices out there!
This is a lot to unload on you, but I need help.
Signed,
Afraid to Start Over
Dear Afraid,
My heart breaks for you. Not just because of what you’re experiencing now, but because you grew up in a home where you didn’t feel safe or loved. And I think a lot of what you’re accepting from your boyfriend and in your previous marriage is because it’s familiar to you.
I’m going to be very direct with you. GET OUT of this relationship. NOW.
The two of you started out messy, and it’s only gotten messier. You don’t respect each other. You acknowledge that you’re both verbally and emotionally abusive. And just because your fights haven’t turned physical doesn’t mean you aren’t doing real serious damage to each other.
You’ve told him that the next time he disrespects you, he’s out of your life. My question is: Why does there need to be a next time? What other awful behavior does this guy have to show you?
And please don’t confuse an apology with a change in behavior. He’s already demonstrated a pattern. He mistreats you … you threaten to leave … he apologizes … things get better for a while, and then you’re right back where you started.
I would strongly encourage you to get professional counseling. You deserved to grow up in a home where you felt safe and loved. You didn’t get that. And that kind of childhood trauma can affect how we see ourselves, what we’re willing to tolerate, and how we treat other people. You’ve acknowledged your own abusive behavior, too. That’s something you need to address before you get into another relationship.
And as for dating in Seattle in your 50s? I hear you. Newly single friends of mine have complained that it’s slim pickings out there. But don’t let the fear that you won’t find someone better convince you to stay with someone who treats you terribly.
Right now, you don’t need another man. You need to focus on healing yourself, rebuilding your self-worth, and getting to a place where you can recognize and be part of a healthy, loving relationship.
Again, break it off NOW. I promise you’ll be much happier and at peace when you’re alone, instead of being with someone who’s making you miserable.
With love,
Ursula
If you have a family or work dilemma, or you need advice after going through a major change, I’m here to help you! Send your question to me on MyNorthwest or email me directly at askursula@bonneville.com.
Listen to Gee and Ursula on “The Gee and Ursula Show” weekday mornings from 9 am to 12 pm on KIRO Newsradio.